http://www.ncaa.org/about/resources...es-committee-adjusts-targeting-rule-defensive
Now if they'd only call illegal shifts and whatnot.
typo in the title
Now if they'd only call illegal shifts and whatnot.
typo in the title
Rules Committee recommends 10 second substitution window
- Thread starter CoachJeff
- Start date
- Status
Re: Rules Ctne recommends 10 second substitution window
It is about time.
I also like how they are looking into the targeting penalty. They want to be able to reverse the 15 yard penalty...if it is ruled as not a targeting situation. Sounds fair to me.
It is about time.
I also like how they are looking into the targeting penalty. They want to be able to reverse the 15 yard penalty...if it is ruled as not a targeting situation. Sounds fair to me.
Re: Rules Ctne recommends 10 second substitution window
Most pundits are vociferously against the defensive sub rule.
Most pundits are vociferously against the defensive sub rule.
Re: Rules Ctne recommends 10 second substitution window
Joe Schad tweeted they are proposing a rule that the offense cannot run a play until there is 29 or less seconds on the play clock.
Joe Schad tweeted they are proposing a rule that the offense cannot run a play until there is 29 or less seconds on the play clock.
Re: Rules Ctne recommends 10 second substitution window
Also, would be nice to call blocking down field on those occasions when the QB acts like he's going to run, finds he can't and then steps back to pass.
Also, would be nice to call blocking down field on those occasions when the QB acts like he's going to run, finds he can't and then steps back to pass.
Re: Rules Ctne recommends 10 second substitution window
They wouldn't need a rule change if they just enforced the rules already on the books.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk, so my fat fingers cause misspellings and autocorrect makes my ships into...
They wouldn't need a rule change if they just enforced the rules already on the books.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk, so my fat fingers cause misspellings and autocorrect makes my ships into...
Re: Rules Ctne recommends 10 second substitution window
Thank goodness. I like the rule about changing the targeting rule around too.
The 10 second window at least allows you to plan your substitutions. Every 4 plays or every 3 plays you can change out like hockey. It will require a lot more depth on teams and situational defense will still be harder to implement.
Thank goodness. I like the rule about changing the targeting rule around too.
The 10 second window at least allows you to plan your substitutions. Every 4 plays or every 3 plays you can change out like hockey. It will require a lot more depth on teams and situational defense will still be harder to implement.
Re: Rules Ctne recommends 10 second substitution window
Probably more than you would think with all the teams running the HUNH.
Re: Rules Ctne recommends 10 second substitution window
Anyway, I think this rule is a step in the right direction but I'm not sure it fixes some of the major problems. For starters, was any study conducted to insure 10 seconds is enough time to substitute? They seemed to look at it from the aspect that it won't really slow teams down, but if you have a banged up player trying to get off the field, is ten seconds enough time for everything to happen? I'd be much happier if they did some sort of study to insure it was actually enough time to substitute. I'm happy with the idea and approach though.
The health issue is a very valid one, as things stand now against a hurry up team, if you're dinged up you have two options really. One would be drop to the ground, and have the crowd booing you for daring to get hurt in a football game, and the other is just stay in there, which obviously isn't something we should force injured players into doing.
I fixed it for you...
Anyway, I think this rule is a step in the right direction but I'm not sure it fixes some of the major problems. For starters, was any study conducted to insure 10 seconds is enough time to substitute? They seemed to look at it from the aspect that it won't really slow teams down, but if you have a banged up player trying to get off the field, is ten seconds enough time for everything to happen? I'd be much happier if they did some sort of study to insure it was actually enough time to substitute. I'm happy with the idea and approach though.
The health issue is a very valid one, as things stand now against a hurry up team, if you're dinged up you have two options really. One would be drop to the ground, and have the crowd booing you for daring to get hurt in a football game, and the other is just stay in there, which obviously isn't something we should force injured players into doing.
Re: Rules Ctne recommends 10 second substitution window
True, but teams always could snap it, which is why the def couldn't really sub. Now, they may have a shot to sub.
Re: Rules Ctne recommends 10 second substitution window
Barners will be in meltdown mode over this! The REC strikes again!
Barners will be in meltdown mode over this! The REC strikes again!
Re: Rules Ctne recommends 10 second substitution window
The article said that the committee found that most teams running the HUNH offense did not snap the ball with 30 seconds remining on the play clock. This rule is trying to offset the the advantage gained by coaches that use the offense to keep existing defensive personnel on the field, look at that personnel and their formations, then call his offensive play based on that.
Re: Rules Ctne recommends 10 second substitution window
A real problem with the substitution rule--it seriously screws up the 2-minute drill.
A real problem with the substitution rule--it seriously screws up the 2-minute drill.
Re: Rules Ctne recommends 10 second substitution window
I hope it passes. I like the fact that it would give coaches a few extra seconds to call their defensive sets and get the players in the right place. I think it would be huge, but.......I don't think it will happen this year.
I hope it passes. I like the fact that it would give coaches a few extra seconds to call their defensive sets and get the players in the right place. I think it would be huge, but.......I don't think it will happen this year.
Re: Rules Ctne recommends 10 second substitution window
It says it won't be during the last 2 minutes of the half or the last 2 minutes of the game.
It says it won't be during the last 2 minutes of the half or the last 2 minutes of the game.
Re: Rules Ctne recommends 10 second substitution window
I like the 10 second rule and really like the targeting one. The targeting rule was really bad the way it was used last year.
I like the 10 second rule and really like the targeting one. The targeting rule was really bad the way it was used last year.
- Status
Latest threads
-
-
Question: Chris Youngblood did he commit over the weekend?
- Started by mlingerfelt31
- Replies: 2
-
-
-
-