How do YOU predict the Playoff Committee will rank the Top 10?

Al A Bama · Oct 27, 2014

Here's my prediction regarding the Playoff Committee's 1st Vote on the Rankings:

1 Florida State = 7 - 0
2 Mississippi State = 7 - 0
3 Notre Dame = 6 - 1
4 Oregon = 7 - 1
5 Auburn = 6 - 1
6 Ole Miss = 7 - 1
7 Alabama = 7 – 1
8 Michigan State = 7 – 1
9 Kansas State 6 – 1
10 TCU = 6 - 1

They may put in another PAC 12 team in the top 10.

I'm looking forward, I think, to the Playoff Committees 1st ranking so that we can critique it.

CrimsonForce · Oct 27, 2014

My prediction of top 4 committee ranking : Mississippi State, Florida State, Alabama, Auburn

81usaf92 · Oct 27, 2014

1.Miss St
2.Fla St
3.Oregon
4.Mich St
5.TCU
6.ND
7.Auburn
8.Ole Miss
9.Alabama
10.Kan St

IMO 7-9 can be in any order, but I think first two out are going to be ND and a One loss Big 12 team. I just dont see them voting on the best 4 teams. I also think they may use this as a statement on their criteria so expect a lower half top 10 placement.

what it should be
1.Miss St
2.Fla St
3.Alabama
4.Auburn
5.Ole Miss
6.ND
7.Mich St
8.Oregon
9.Kan St
10.TCU

PacadermaTideUs · Oct 27, 2014

1. Mississippi State
2. Florida State
3. Notre Dame
4. Oregon
5. Mississippi
6. Alabama
7. Michigan State
8. Auburn
9. Georgia
10. TCU

Catfish · Oct 27, 2014

Al A Bama said:
Here's my prediction regarding the Playoff Committee's 1st Vote on the Rankings:

1 Florida State = 7 - 0
2 Mississippi State = 7 - 0
3 Notre Dame = 6 - 1
4 Oregon = 7 - 1
5 Auburn = 6 - 1
6 Ole Miss = 7 - 1
7 Alabama = 7 – 1
8 Michigan State = 7 – 1
9 Kansas State 6 – 1
10 TCU = 6 - 1

That looks about like what I expect. When the final four comes out, I'll be shocked if it's not made up entirely of conference champions and ND, assuming ND wins out. IMO, if we have four teams that have one loss or less and are conference champions (or ND), there won't be two teams from any conference. They'll take the easy way out.

CrimsonForce · Oct 27, 2014

Who is TCUs big win? Was it Oklahoma?

TideEngineer08 · Oct 27, 2014

I really hate the Notre Dame factor. But they will be in the top 4, IMO.

1. MSU
2. FSU
3. Notre Dame
4. Oregon
5. Alabama
6. Auburn
7. Ole Miss
8. Michigan State
9. Kansas State
10. TCU

Al A Bama · Oct 27, 2014

CrimsonForce said:
Who is TCUs big win? Was it Oklahoma?

Minnesota and Oklahoma plus those 82 points they scored in their last game. Did those 82 points ring the Playoff Committee's bell? Another BIG win was Samford?!?

GreatDanish · Oct 27, 2014

1. MSU
2. FSU
3. Alabama
4. Auburn
5. Ole Miss
6. Oregon
7, Notre Dame
8. Georgia
9. Michigan State
10. TCU

bamaga · Oct 27, 2014

Msu
fsu
oregon
nd
bama
michigan state
ole miss
tcu

BroadwayJoe777 · Oct 27, 2014

When are these clowns going to make their first poll?

bamaga · Oct 27, 2014

CrimsonForce said:
Who is TCUs big win? Was it Oklahoma?

Scoring 82. Which, by the way, was by no means TCU's way of running up the score to impress voters.

Catfish · Oct 27, 2014

bamaga said:
Scoring 82. Which, by the way, was by no means TCU's way of running up the score to impress voters.

I'm not even sure putting up 82 on Texas Tech's "defense" is all that impressive.

RTR91 · Oct 27, 2014

bamaga said:
Scoring 82. Which, by the way, was by no means TCU's way of running up the score to impress voters.

Their starting QB was throwing passes with 1:14 left in the third quarter while ahead 61-27. That'st not running up the score to impress?

PacadermaTideUs · Oct 27, 2014

BroadwayJoe777 said:
When are these clowns going to make their first poll?

Tomorrow night

Bama Lee · Oct 27, 2014

1. Mississippi State
2. Florida State
3. Alabama
4. Oregon
5. Auburn
6. Notre Dame
7. Michigan State
8. TCU
9. Ole Miss
10. Kansas State

oregonbltzkrieg · Oct 27, 2014

Notre Dame doesn't belong in the top 4 now or at the end of the season if there are still lots of 1 loss teams. They don't have a single good win. They play garbage teams for the most part and barely beat a poor Stanford team. They lost to FSU. That doesn't tell us much, because FSU plays nobodies all season long. They are not in a conference so they won't have to win a conference championship. They should be on the outside looking in, if things are fair. Also, after their pathetic performance in the NCG a few years ago, no one wants to see them anywhere near the playoffs.

Ldlane · Oct 27, 2014

I'll predict that Bama will be on the outside until we beat LSU and/or MSU. 1. MSU, 2. FSU, 3. Oregon, 4. Notre Dame, 5. Georgia, 6. Alabama, 7. Auburn 8. Michigan State, 9. Ole Miss, 10. Kansas State.

TrueCrimson7 · Oct 27, 2014

Hate it, but I believe the true reason for this committee is NOT to pick the best 4 teams but to pick the top 4 teams that will cause the least uproar nationwide. Picking teams from different conferences for the top spots will be most "satisfactory." The problem is that people will be using this poll to 1) reset their thoughts on the top teams, and 2) use it to justify their statements that the SEC aren't as good as we know it is. Auburn has a "better loss" than us right now. But if we win out, I still believe we make it in the top 4.

Another prediction here....if there are two SEC teams in the FINAL four spots, they will be placed 1-4 or 2-3 so that they go head to head in the first playoff round. No SEC vs. SEC championship. Problem solved.

1. Mississippi State
2. Florida State
3. Oregon
4. Notre Dame
5. Auburn
6. Alabama
7. Michigan State
8. TCU
9. Kansas State
10. Ole Miss

BroadwayJoe777 · Oct 27, 2014

PacadermaTideUs said:
Tomorrow night

Thanks!

How do YOU predict the Playoff Committee will rank the Top 10?

Hall of Fame

Hall of Fame

TideFans Legend

All-American

Hall of Fame

Hall of Fame

TideFans Legend

Hall of Fame

Hall of Fame

Hall of Fame

BroadwayJoe777

Guest

Hall of Fame

Hall of Fame

Super Moderator

All-American

All-American

1st Team

Hall of Fame

All-American

BroadwayJoe777

Guest

TideFans.shop - NEW Stuff!