I hereby amend my answer that Paul as analyst is MUCH preferred to Paul the radio pot-stirrer with clueless minions. Still not my fave, but I definitely agree that as an analyst, he has exceeded my expectations.Not a popular answer, but for me, it's Finebaum. Mind you, I'm not talking about his radio show and his cast of clowns. When he's in an analyst role, he cuts to the chase and provides clear answers and predictions, without a lot of extra fluff.
His radio co-host on the other hand is highly annoying to me. Taylor Zarzour or something like that.McElroy has improved a ton over the season. He was hard to listen to at first but he's one of their better analysts right now.