Massey's Composite:
http://www.masseyratings.com/cf/compare.htm
Notice...
Alabama's lowest ranking in all of the 108 rankings is #6. The only teams that have AVERAGES better than that are Oregon and Ole Miss. We're ranked #1 in 66 of the 108 rankings.
In Sagarin's rankings, we have 7 wins against top 30 teams. Only Auburn and LSU have even played 7 top 30 teams. The SEC has the highest rated one-loss team, two-loss team, three-loss team, four-loss team, five-loss team, and six-loss team.
At this point in the season, it would be tough to find really good evidence that another team should be ranked #1.
FSU has zero wins against top 25 teams. Well, Clemson is #25 in Sagarin's composite rankings. It doesn't matter, though. Oregon, FSU, and Bama are the top 3 in some order. They're all in if they win. But for my own sanity, I really really hope FSU is not #1 or #2.