Question: Who thought Sylve had an int?

Bamaro · Nov 30, 2014

I know its a moot point but just curious how you all saw it. All camera angles seemed to show a Bray catch except one that showed the Marshall pass clearly hit Sylve in the chest and he pull it in.
Glad this didn't effect the outcome of the game.

JustNeedMe81 · Nov 30, 2014

It was a wrong call. Slyve had it.

CrimsonTut · Nov 30, 2014

I initially thought it was an Auburn reception. After watching the replays I thought it was an INT. Mike Pereira even Tweeted he thought it should've been Bama's ball.

im4datide · Nov 30, 2014

yeah I thought that was a BS call..the whole tie goes to the receiver thing is a joke IMHO

92tide · Nov 30, 2014

i think he did get the interruption, i don't know that there was enough on the review to overturn a call on the field

TexasBama · Nov 30, 2014

Either Sylve had an int or he was out of bounds.

NationalTitles18 · Nov 30, 2014

http://www.foxsports.com/college-fo...s-refs-calls-rules-replay-mike-pereira-112914

Let’s look at the NCAA Rule Book, Part 2, under "interpretations'' for the answer. Under the Completed Pass, Article 6, rule 7-3-6, section 2: Two opposing players receive a legal forward pass while both are off the ground, and one payer returns to the ground inbounds before the other. Ruling: No simultaneous catch. The legal forward pass is completed or intercepted by the player who first returned to the ground.

Hooks4bama · Nov 30, 2014

http://www.foxsports.com/college-fo...s-refs-calls-rules-replay-mike-pereira-112914

braggtd · Nov 30, 2014

I think that was one of those situations where the play stands as called because the evidence wasn't strong enough to support an overturn. Had the call gone the other way it would have stood too. Looking at these pictures...I think it was a bad call.

bamagradinATL · Nov 30, 2014

My thoughts were at best interception, at worse incomplete pass.

DzynKingRTR · Nov 30, 2014

everybody watching except Barn fans and the refs.

bamagradinATL · Nov 30, 2014

im4datide said:
yeah I thought that was a BS call..the whole tie goes to the receiver thing is a joke IMHO

The LSU game in 2011 proved that....

TDBama78 · Nov 30, 2014

At a minimum Sylvie had half of it. So the tie went to the runner I guess. I thought they should have called incomplete at the very least.

RollTideMang · Nov 30, 2014

When I saw it, I didn't think either really had full possession before sylve was out of bounds. I didn't even think INT until the announcers mentioned it.

Rush · Nov 30, 2014

Anyone know why it was Sylve was put into the game instead of Tony Brown?

Alasippi · Nov 30, 2014

Rush said:
Anyone know why it was Sylve was put into the game instead of Tony Brown?

We put Brown in and then replaced him with Sylve.

GulfCoastTider · Nov 30, 2014

That was a horrible call. That play was either one of two things: An incomplete pass or an interception.

I don't normally complain about individual bad calls because the best way to avoid being affected by them is to have enough of a lead so that they don't have an impact. But in this particular game, the officiating was lousy at worst and poor at best.

The crew missed 576,209 holding calls and at least 332 hands to the face.

I exaggerate to make the point that officiating in the SEC is getting as bad as it is in the Big 12. It's not just in our games, either. It's a league wide problem and it's been that way for far too long.

Lassr4Bama · Nov 30, 2014

It's terrible when I know the rules more than the official. I knew it was an interception. I told my wife it was an interception after the replay because Bama had both hands on the ball. Auburn had one and Sylvie came down first in bounds. I was just flabbergasted when they confirmed the Auburn catch. I thought at worse they would say the play stands as called but to confirm it shows the SEC replay official is just as bad as the other SEC officials.

day-day · Nov 30, 2014

I initially thought is was a tie so it was an AU reception. After seeing the clear photos and especially the rule regarding the 1st player to contact the ground, I know this was a Bama interception.

WPtider · Nov 30, 2014

It looked like Sylve had it and was out of bounds. The real discussion is the improvement Sylve showed from game 1 last night and if he is the answer as the starter going forward? Coming out of Ms State I thought our secondary had improved. Coming out of WCU I thought E. Jackson was our best corner and C. Jones was pretty weak. Last night C. Jones played pretty well and Jackson was bad. They dictated a few match ups with Williams being covered by M Smith but we managed that pretty well. I think the only consistency in the secondary is the improvement Nick Perry has shown.

Question: Who thought Sylve had an int?

TideFans Legend

Hall of Fame

1st Team

All-SEC

TideFans Legend

TideFans Legend

TideFans Legend

1st Team

Suspended

All-American

TideFans Legend

All-American

All-American

All-American

All-American

Suspended

Hall of Fame

1st Team

Hall of Fame

1st Team

TideFans.shop - NEW Stuff!