Chris Schenkel and Keith Jackson are in my Hall of Fame with Keith at the very top. I also like Al Michaels. Verne is pretty good also.
Dr. Lou is in my Hall of Shame!
Loved Schenkel and Wilkinson
Loved Keith and Frank Broyles
Keith and Griese were pretty good as well
Love Kessler and Blackledge
Love Musburger and Herbie
Not big on Fowler/Herbie for some reason. Not sure why.
Verne and Gary are really good though. The one thing Verne excels at in my opinion is that he'll let the play unfold with very little play by play. He realizes that we're watching it on television. So rather than boring us with "He's at the 35-40-45 he simply makes suttle comments that ad to the play.
A great example would be Blake Sims brilliant TD run against Florida(I believe). Verne's entire play call was basically.."Sim's....my goodness......my goodness....MYYYYY Goodness...Touchdown Alabama""....He was referring to the moves Blake made but he made it more exciting by his "Non play by play"..
There's an art to that that takes many years to develop.