Well lets hope we get to see. For now agree to disagree.That's incorrect. Notre Dame isn't getting jumped by Oklahoma State if they both win out..
Well lets hope we get to see. For now agree to disagree.That's incorrect. Notre Dame isn't getting jumped by Oklahoma State if they both win out..
That's incorrect. Notre Dame isn't getting jumped by Oklahoma State if they both win out..
Well lets hope we get to see. For now agree to disagree.
I would think an undefeated Big 12 champion with wins over OU, Baylor, and TCU would jump a one loss Notre Dame team. Of course, this committee can pretty much do whatever they like, but they have stressed conference champions since their inception, so an undefeated conference champion should trump a one loss independent that keeps tooting its horn about losing a close game.That's incorrect. Notre Dame isn't getting jumped by Oklahoma State if they both win out..
"worst loss" didn't keep ohio st out last year........Of course. Just sharing my opinion that a BIG12 team will not jump Notre Dame. I don't think Oklahoma State will win out and Oklahoma has the worse loss of any team being considered..
Completely different situation friend. OSU played in a CCG and beat Wisconsin 59-0. The BIG12 doesn't have a CCG.."worst loss" didn't keep ohio st out last year........
OK ST's OOC schedule is garbage. Yes they are undefeated but they have a lot of narrow victories vs bad teams. Their 2 best wins vs TCU and (presumably) Baylor would be somewhat tainted because TCU is without Boykin and Doctson and Baylor is without their starting QB. I don't feel it's fair to penalize OK ST for playing TCU and Baylor when they are not at full strength but the committee will take that into consideration. I think this discussion will take care of itself when OK ST loses to Baylor or Oklahoma. With all that being said I really hope OK ST does make the CFP because I think it would be an easy victory..I'm actually shocked that people think a 12-0 Oklahoma State (after beating 8-1 Baylor and possibly 10-1 OU) wouldn't be ahead of Notre Dame (playing BC and Stanford) in the end.
Arguing Oklahoma over Notre Dame is one thing, but there is no way an undefeated P5 school is being left out unless there is a crazy year where there are 4 or 5 of them.
I would prefer Notre Dame to be left out because in the Big 12-2 does schedule 9 conference games and a conference champion is crowned on the results of the games during the season.Aside from what everyone THINKS will happen, and not taking into consideration schedules and wins/losses etc, Im curious which everyone would prefer:
1) The Big 12-2 to be left out because they dont play a conference championship game
or
2) Notre Dame being left out because they refuse to join a conference.
I'm split on this one, but think I'd prefer Notre Dame being left out since they are bucking the system more than the Big 12-2.
Thoughts??
I would rather Notre Dame be left out because I think they are a better team than Oklahoma and much better than Oklahoma State. I just want what's best for Bama which is a win..Aside from what everyone THINKS will happen, and not taking into consideration schedules and wins/losses etc, Im curious which everyone would prefer:
1) The Big 12-2 to be left out because they dont play a conference championship game
or
2) Notre Dame being left out because they refuse to join a conference.
I'm split on this one, but think I'd prefer Notre Dame being left out since they are bucking the system more than the Big 12-2.
Thoughts??
So you are the one who said if Colt hadn't got hurt....:biggrin:I would rather Notre Dame be left out because I think they are a better team than Oklahoma and much better than Oklahoma State. I just want what's best for Bama which is a win..
Leave out OSUw. But not because they don't have a CCG.Aside from what everyone THINKS will happen, and not taking into consideration schedules and wins/losses etc, Im curious which everyone would prefer:
1) The Big 12-2 to be left out because they dont play a conference championship game
or
2) Notre Dame being left out because they refuse to join a conference.
I'm split on this one, but think I'd prefer Notre Dame being left out since they are bucking the system more than the Big 12-2.
Thoughts??
It would be more fun for me to see our team embarrass Notre Dame again, but I admit that is mostly due to my childhood. It really doesn't matter that much to me. I just enjoy digging through what they are looking at.Aside from what everyone THINKS will happen, and not taking into consideration schedules and wins/losses etc, Im curious which everyone would prefer:
1) The Big 12-2 to be left out because they dont play a conference championship game
or
2) Notre Dame being left out because they refuse to join a conference.
I'm split on this one, but think I'd prefer Notre Dame being left out since they are bucking the system more than the Big 12-2.
Thoughts??
I would prefer Houston getting in and both ND and Okie Light play each other on Christmas Eve or something nice like that.Aside from what everyone THINKS will happen, and not taking into consideration schedules and wins/losses etc, Im curious which everyone would prefer:
1) The Big 12-2 to be left out because they dont play a conference championship game
or
2) Notre Dame being left out because they refuse to join a conference.
I'm split on this one, but think I'd prefer Notre Dame being left out since they are bucking the system more than the Big 12-2.
Thoughts??
After thinking about this ALL day, I've decided that a PAC-12 (2 loss) Championship team or an Undefeated Oklahoma State or one loss Oklahoma team from the Big 12-2 deserves to be in the National Championship Playoffs over Notre Dame. Notre Dame should NOT be considered unless they are a Conference Champion. Now, I've already said Oklahoma had a VERY Bad loss to UTw, but a champion is a champion. What would Notre Dame be a CHAMPION of? Their dreams?Aside from what everyone THINKS will happen, and not taking into consideration schedules and wins/losses etc, Im curious which everyone would prefer:
1) The Big 12-2 to be left out because they dont play a conference championship game
or
2) Notre Dame being left out because they refuse to join a conference.
I'm split on this one, but think I'd prefer Notre Dame being left out since they are bucking the system more than the Big 12-2.
Thoughts??