Re: Brent Key to be Alabama OL coach
It's never an easy thing to criticize (or "self-evaluate") Alabama in front of a bunch of Alabama fans, because we all want to think everything is fine.
The OL play from this past year was not fine. It wasn't bad, but it wasn't exemplary, nor was it commensurate with the amount of talent on-hand. That's not to say the OL didn't do some things very well. As rgw has mentioned, the power-run game, especially behind Shank and Jackson, worked really well -- despite having a revolving door at tight end (four different starters at the Y position in 2015). Ryan Kelly had a tremendous year, really just a handful of bad plays. Pierschbacher did as well as one could expect from a freshman.
On the other hand, anyone who watched the Clemson game was reminded of what Alabama has dealt with on the OL right side (and even the left, really) all year: Pass-pro issues. We preach the STAT system (Snap To Affect Time) here every year, the measurement of how fast it takes a QB to reroute after the center snaps the ball. Anything under 3 seconds is iffy. Anything under 2.5 is troubling. Anything under 2.0 is horrid. Grab a stopwatch and go back and check some of those plays against Clemson. Try not to cover your eyes.
When we preview spring training in a couple of weeks, one of the things we're going to spend some time talking about is whether Taylor's hold on the RG position is solid. Very few returning starters in the Saban years have lost their jobs heading into their senior season. But when you look at some of the talent that's coming in along the OL right now, especially with the C/G group getting a new coach, it's not out of the realm of possibility.
We can talk about whether some of the struggles (like Robinson's) was due mainly to injury, or whether it was technique or coaching philosophy, but like anything else, in the end, "ball don't lie." Alabama's QBs spent too much time getting bucked around and if Damien Harris or Kenyan Drake had been the bellcow back rather than Henry, who knows where the running game finishes.