Re: 2016 Season QB Thread (Moved QB Posts from Practice Thread)
you must be a Shannarah guy
How bout JH Hammer instead?
you must be a Shannarah guy
2016 Season QB Thread
- Thread starter BamaMoon
- Start date
Re: 2016 Season QB Thread (Moved QB Posts from Practice Thread)
They'll probably work Hurts in here and there to start the season.
But don't be surprised to see him start against USC, and if he were to stumble significantly early, then more seniority would step in.
They'll probably work Hurts in here and there to start the season.
But don't be surprised to see him start against USC, and if he were to stumble significantly early, then more seniority would step in.
Re: 2016 Season QB Thread (Moved QB Posts from Practice Thread)
Yeah I have to agree with a lot of folks on here. Seems people who see the QBs play are all saying Hurts is the best QB on the field. This is interesting for sure to see if a freshman dual threat phenom can actually break through and win over the coaches and the team.
Yeah I have to agree with a lot of folks on here. Seems people who see the QBs play are all saying Hurts is the best QB on the field. This is interesting for sure to see if a freshman dual threat phenom can actually break through and win over the coaches and the team.
Re: 2016 Season QB Thread (Moved QB Posts from Practice Thread)
I'm really excited about the possibility of Hurts being our QB. You can tell he has it...I don't see how you keep him off the field. I think his extra mobility will give teams fits. The fact that he has the arm to go with it is really special. I see Hurts becoming a Deshaun Watson type quarterback (a very special player). As everyone knows he will make mistakes but I believe he can and will overcome it. Priority one is take care of the ball...then everything else will work itself out.
I'm really excited about the possibility of Hurts being our QB. You can tell he has it...I don't see how you keep him off the field. I think his extra mobility will give teams fits. The fact that he has the arm to go with it is really special. I see Hurts becoming a Deshaun Watson type quarterback (a very special player). As everyone knows he will make mistakes but I believe he can and will overcome it. Priority one is take care of the ball...then everything else will work itself out.
Re: 2016 Season QB Thread (Moved QB Posts from Practice Thread)
That would be great if Hurts did start this year. It would be nice to have a three year starter at QB.
But that Hawaiian QB recruit is incredibly talented , too......maybe even ahead of Hurts at this point in his career. Tua might even beat out Hurts next year, who knows for sure.
Great problem to have, either way.
That would be great if Hurts did start this year. It would be nice to have a three year starter at QB.
But that Hawaiian QB recruit is incredibly talented , too......maybe even ahead of Hurts at this point in his career. Tua might even beat out Hurts next year, who knows for sure.
Great problem to have, either way.
Re: 2016 Season QB Thread (Moved QB Posts from Practice Thread)
I'm firmly in the "I'll believe it when I see it" camp; but if the rumblings are true about his talent, he can take care of the ball, and he wins over those he needs to then Roll Tide!
I'm firmly in the "I'll believe it when I see it" camp; but if the rumblings are true about his talent, he can take care of the ball, and he wins over those he needs to then Roll Tide!
Re: 2016 Season QB Thread (Moved QB Posts from Practice Thread)
Even Deshaun Watson had a few very bad throws, but his talent overshadowed it. That could be the case with Hurts. Notice what Saban said what he learned from the scrimmage. He said something to the effect that he wanted to see some things under game conditions at the QB position, and he did. Multiple reports that Hurts was the best QB, stood out for sure. Hmmmmmm
Re: 2016 Season QB Thread (Moved QB Posts from Practice Thread)
Experience counts for a lot, but it has to carry over to the field. Based on the limited number of reports out of camp so far, it seem Cooper is struggling with his throws.
Last edited:
Re: 2016 Season QB Thread (Moved QB Posts from Practice Thread)
Well we have something to talk about for the next couple of weeks.
What we all want is for the QB who can do the best job to be selected. We will find out soon. I wonder if it could be we play both of them, like running the Wildcat, or something like Urban did at Florida when he would put Tebow in down close to the goal line?
Well we have something to talk about for the next couple of weeks.
What we all want is for the QB who can do the best job to be selected. We will find out soon. I wonder if it could be we play both of them, like running the Wildcat, or something like Urban did at Florida when he would put Tebow in down close to the goal line?
Re: 2016 Season QB Thread (Moved QB Posts from Practice Thread)
It's obvious that we are transitioning the QB position to one with more athleticism and less game manager type skill set. Bateman would have been the transition QB but his lack of arm talent (if you believe the reports) with the receivers we have may mean its time to make the switch now and roll the dice a little. Barnett, Hurts, and hopefully Tua will have us stacked for the foreseeable future.
It's obvious that we are transitioning the QB position to one with more athleticism and less game manager type skill set. Bateman would have been the transition QB but his lack of arm talent (if you believe the reports) with the receivers we have may mean its time to make the switch now and roll the dice a little. Barnett, Hurts, and hopefully Tua will have us stacked for the foreseeable future.
2016 Season QB Thread (Moved QB Posts from Practice Thread)
Based on nothing more than speculation my guess is we see a game much like Wiscy with Bateman going first followed by Barnett. My guess is BB wins the job and starts after that - with Bateman listed as the official 2 - but Hurts the real 2 were BB to go down.
Probably missed by a mile - but as long as we are WAG'ing I figured I would get in on the fun [emoji57]
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Based on nothing more than speculation my guess is we see a game much like Wiscy with Bateman going first followed by Barnett. My guess is BB wins the job and starts after that - with Bateman listed as the official 2 - but Hurts the real 2 were BB to go down.
Probably missed by a mile - but as long as we are WAG'ing I figured I would get in on the fun [emoji57]
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Last edited:
Re: 2016 Season QB Thread (Moved QB Posts from Practice Thread)
I keep hearing Hurts is the early leader. I still think it is truly up for grabs but I think it will be one of the young guns BB or JH. I love that CNS really does give all the guys a shot regardless of age.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I keep hearing Hurts is the early leader. I still think it is truly up for grabs but I think it will be one of the young guns BB or JH. I love that CNS really does give all the guys a shot regardless of age.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Re: 2016 Season QB Thread (Moved QB Posts from Practice Thread)
Winston Churchill said, of the admiral of England's Grand Fleet in World War 1, that he was the only man on either side who could lose the war in an afternoon.
This is a very concise description of why Saban likes experience, consistency in performance, and lack of mental errors in his QB. This football team is very like that Grand Fleet - the biggest, fastest, most powerful, the most determined and experienced. But you can still lose, be defeated in detail, with too many mistakes by the admiral.
Quarterbacks on other teams need to win. The Alabama QB is surrounded by the Grand Fleet. Winning is a team effort and the QB must not lose.
Bateman is going to be the starting QB, unless he keeps throwing interceptions in practice.
Winston Churchill said, of the admiral of England's Grand Fleet in World War 1, that he was the only man on either side who could lose the war in an afternoon.
This is a very concise description of why Saban likes experience, consistency in performance, and lack of mental errors in his QB. This football team is very like that Grand Fleet - the biggest, fastest, most powerful, the most determined and experienced. But you can still lose, be defeated in detail, with too many mistakes by the admiral.
Quarterbacks on other teams need to win. The Alabama QB is surrounded by the Grand Fleet. Winning is a team effort and the QB must not lose.
Bateman is going to be the starting QB, unless he keeps throwing interceptions in practice.
Re: 2016 Season QB Thread (Moved QB Posts from Practice Thread)
USC is going to be in a real pickle if Hurts is the starter. I doubt they will be preparing for him on game week and we all know Saban will not name a starter. We are going to hear the same stuff until someone trots onto the field in a few weeks.
USC is going to be in a real pickle if Hurts is the starter. I doubt they will be preparing for him on game week and we all know Saban will not name a starter. We are going to hear the same stuff until someone trots onto the field in a few weeks.
Re: 2016 Season QB Thread (Moved QB Posts from Practice Thread)
Obviously there is a tactical advantage in not allowing your opponent to know who to prepare for in the 1st game of the season. HOWEVER, there is no collegiate tape on Barnett or Hurts outside of A-Day and Bateman's is very limited. So I don't know how much advantage is to be gained - not to mention with all the new personnel on the offensive side it's likely that Kiffin has yet again drawn up offensive wrinkles that USC will not have prepared for (and vice-versa), though many here have correctly reduced the core of his offensive strategy into a few key elements.
However, it may simply just be best to keep it under wraps until the day arrives. The team may know who gets the nod, and it may not create a huge advantage but psychologically it allows Alabama to hold the chips in a way.
I agree and disagree.
Obviously there is a tactical advantage in not allowing your opponent to know who to prepare for in the 1st game of the season. HOWEVER, there is no collegiate tape on Barnett or Hurts outside of A-Day and Bateman's is very limited. So I don't know how much advantage is to be gained - not to mention with all the new personnel on the offensive side it's likely that Kiffin has yet again drawn up offensive wrinkles that USC will not have prepared for (and vice-versa), though many here have correctly reduced the core of his offensive strategy into a few key elements.
However, it may simply just be best to keep it under wraps until the day arrives. The team may know who gets the nod, and it may not create a huge advantage but psychologically it allows Alabama to hold the chips in a way.
Re: 2016 Season QB Thread (Moved QB Posts from Practice Thread)
Boys, I don't think anybody has a clue this year. I've THOUGHT it would eventually end up being Barnett with Bateman getting a look too, but now with Hurts being a possibility it's all just a big guess.
I know everybody can guess, but I'm ammused at those who speak/write as if they know what is going to happen.
Boys, I don't think anybody has a clue this year. I've THOUGHT it would eventually end up being Barnett with Bateman getting a look too, but now with Hurts being a possibility it's all just a big guess.
I know everybody can guess, but I'm ammused at those who speak/write as if they know what is going to happen.
Re: 2016 Season QB Thread (Moved QB Posts from Practice Thread)
As for comparisons, Hurts looks to be wired up like B. Sims, IMO. Both athletic, good arms, good legs. Tua V., if we can keep him, looks like a continuation in that direction for future qb profile. Very impressed with what Tua looks to bring to the table. Much like Hurts/Sims, only left-handed. Check out some of his highlights if you haven't already. Plenty out there.
As for comparisons, Hurts looks to be wired up like B. Sims, IMO. Both athletic, good arms, good legs. Tua V., if we can keep him, looks like a continuation in that direction for future qb profile. Very impressed with what Tua looks to bring to the table. Much like Hurts/Sims, only left-handed. Check out some of his highlights if you haven't already. Plenty out there.
Re: 2016 Season QB Thread (Moved QB Posts from Practice Thread)
I think we play both Barnett and Hurts
I think we play both Barnett and Hurts
Re: 2016 Season QB Thread (Moved QB Posts from Practice Thread)
I've honestly been thinking that the season would start with Bateman and Barnett playing the first couple of games to see who was the best option in a Live Game. Then barring disaster Hurts would be able to be redshirted.
But....if you go by what people are saying they have claimed to see in practice and scrimmages my mind is changing. Bateman is struggling to make the throws and actually has had the most turnovers while Barnett has calmed down a bit and playing smarter and Hurts is sizzling.
If I had to guess now....the season starts with Barnett and Hurts playing in the first two games to see who is the best option in a Live Game. Then if for some reason they both fail say due to making one bad decision after another including horrible turnovers we turn to Bateman as a last resort.
It's starting to look like we start 1 freshman....backed up by another. A bit unnerving with 2 new RB starters and about 3 new OL starters.
I've honestly been thinking that the season would start with Bateman and Barnett playing the first couple of games to see who was the best option in a Live Game. Then barring disaster Hurts would be able to be redshirted.
But....if you go by what people are saying they have claimed to see in practice and scrimmages my mind is changing. Bateman is struggling to make the throws and actually has had the most turnovers while Barnett has calmed down a bit and playing smarter and Hurts is sizzling.
If I had to guess now....the season starts with Barnett and Hurts playing in the first two games to see who is the best option in a Live Game. Then if for some reason they both fail say due to making one bad decision after another including horrible turnovers we turn to Bateman as a last resort.
It's starting to look like we start 1 freshman....backed up by another. A bit unnerving with 2 new RB starters and about 3 new OL starters.
Latest threads
-
-
-
Political Meme - Cartoon/Joke Thread...Part XX- Started by Bazza
- Replies: 9
-
US Army replacing 5.56mm rifle with a 6.8mm for infantry- Started by Tidewater
- Replies: 6
-
-
Game One of Alabama-Texas A&M Alabama Series Moved to Friday as Part of Doubleheader- Started by Diamond Tide
- Replies: 0