We would still need some governing body. Otherwise it could get even worse. Defund the NCAA is a nice idea, but think it thru first
The problem with the NCAA was that they were just as two-faced as any sort of partisan-type organization could possibly be WHILE CLAIMING AND PRETENDING to be impartial. That was the problem some of us had with it - not that we don't need some sort of oversight (this is kinda common sense as your post makes that point clear), but we need something resembling CONSISTENT oversight. Jerry Tarkanian's eloquent insult wasn't exactly wrong: "The NCAA is so mad at Kentucky, they're going to give Cleveland State another year of probation."
There was never ANYTHING resembling consistency with those goofs. In 1992, they sanctioned THE ENTIRE UNIVERSITY OF TULSA athletic programs across the board for violations that occurred on the track team. They stripped the women's golf team of a national championship won four years earlier and banned them from post-season competition for a year...yes, you're reading it correctly: they punished the women's golf team for violations committed by the track and field teams. Oh - and the track and field teams got NO ADDITIONAL sanctions while their basketball team was immediately ineligible for the tournament for one year.
I mean, who was giving oversight to the NCAA in this thing?
(And does anyone here REALLY believe that if it had been, say, Texas or Oklahoma caught with the level of SMU scandal that they would have administered the kill shot they gave that school? Everyone knows better).
Maybe retire that playoff committee and put them in charge of oversight.
It wouldn't be any worse than what we've seen given they have to send folks out of the room.