Utah, Baylor, Penn State have SO much ground to make up..
That's the problem, they don't. Alabama is 4th in the mythical BCS standings. 4th in the polls, they are 3rd in FPI, and unfortunately none of that matters.
The committee has shown they can and will do what they want, but they've doggedly stuck to the quality wins metric which is not Alabama's friend here. Even if we assume that conference championship doesn't matter, that's still in the least one more quality win.
I'll show you the problem by referencing Sagarin's SoS:
Ohio State SoS 34
LSU SoS 13
Both those teams are in the clubhouse. Ohio State still has Penn State coming up, meaning their SoS will be rock solid by the time this is all said and done.
Clemson SoS 71
This is the lone undefeated team that should fall completely out of the discussion if they lose. They don't have any quality games to make up SoS.
Alabama SoS 54
Alabama's SoS should climb a bit after the Auburn game, but they're just not going to have a high SoS no matter what. They've usually had this to fall back on, but not this year.
Oregon SoS 30
Their loss to Auburn is the only helpful thing, but they have a good enough SoS that they could be trouble either way. They're almost certain to play Utah in the championship game, which means their SoS goes up even more.
Utah SoS 47
Their SoS isn't great, but if they beat Oregon it will end up ahead of Alabama most likely, and they'll have that shouldn't count but does conference championship.
Oklahoma SoS 41
There's a reason the Big 12 got special permission for a conference championship game and this season is an example. Without it they wouldn't get a push as a one loss team trying to overtake Alabama, but as it stands just playing in that game gives them an SoS boost they wouldn't get otherwise, meaning they are going to break into the top 40 if they play in that game.
Baylor SoS 58
That number is too close to Alabama's, and remember they're undefeated. They win out, they get in above Alabama no questions asked. The problem is even if they stumble, a one loss Baylor that beats Oklahoma in the championship game will find themselves with a comparable SoS to Alabama, but also a conference championship, which supposedly matters.
Minnesota SoS 70
This might seem like a Clemson situation, but it's not. They have two ranked teams coming up, and a potential matchup with Ohio State. Even if they lose one of the two upcoming games, a win over Ohio State could two Big 10 teams in the playoffs.
Penn State SoS 23
If they beat Ohio State, we're looking at another two Big 10 team scenario.
So... we have 6 teams that need to lose once, may be twice to actually completely clear the path for Alabama. I didn't even count Georgia who is in if they win out.
In the past the committee has really not looked at SoS metrics - they have looked at quality wins and losses.
True, I'm using SoS as a stand in because I'm a little lazy and they haven't fully revealed their quality win metric. They do use an SoS calculation to. One thing is clear,
every conference championship victory will be an additional quality win. It's like a double bonus... It shouldn't be, but it is.
And yes, Auburn beating Georgia will be beneficial to Alabama's hopes in multiple ways.