Question: The All-Saban Alabama Team

Alasippi

Suspended
Aug 31, 2007
12,875
2
57
Ocean Springs, MS
QB- A.J.
RB- Trent
HB- Smelley
TE- Michael Williams
RT- Johnson
RG- Steen
C- Barrett
LG- Warmack
LT- Smith
Wr- Julio
Wr- Cooper

NT- Cody
DE- Deadrick
DE- Dareus
LB- CJ
LB- Mclain
LB- Hightower
Nickel- Arenas
Corner- Milliner
Corner- Kirkpatrick
SS- Barron
FS- Rashad

PK- Tiffin
Punter- Mandel

PR-Arenas
KR-Arenas

Very hard calls but there ya go.

sip
 

NCbamagirl

BamaNation Citizen
Jan 30, 2006
47
0
25
49
I'm surprised Colin Peek isn't getting more love at TE. He was one of my favorites when he was here.
 

TideFan in AU

Hall of Fame
QB- A.J. McCarron
RB- Mark Ingram. RB- Trent Richardson
HB- Brad Smelley
TE- Colin Peek
RT- DJ Fluker
RG- Barrett Jones. C- Antoine Caldwell
LG- Chance Warmack
LT- Andre Smith
Wr- Julio Jones
Wr- Amari Cooper

NT- Terrence Cody
DE- Jesse Williams
DE- Marcel Dareus
LB- CJ Mosley
LB- Rolando Mclain
LB- Dont'a Hightower. Jack- Courtney Upshaw
Nickel- Javier Arenas
Corner- Kareem Jackson
Corner- Dre Kirkpatrick
SS- Mark Barron
FS- Rashad Johnson

PK- Leigh Tiffin
Punter- Cody Mandel

PR-Javier Arenas
KR-Javier Arenas 2nd Team. QB- Greg McElroy
RB- Eddie Lacy. RB- TJ Yeldon
HB- Preston Dial
TE- Micheal Williams
RT- Cyrus Kouandjio
RG- Anthony Steen
C- William Vlachos
LG- Mike Johnson
LT- James Carpenter
Wr- Marquis Maze
Wr- Kevin Norwood

NT- Josh Chapman
DE- Brandon Deadrick
DE- Wallace Gilberry
LB- Jerrell Harris
LB- Nico Johnson
LB- Corey Reamer. Jack- Eryk Anders
Nickel- Marquis Johnson
Corner- Dee Milliner
Corner- Dequan Menzie
SS- Robert Lester
FS- HaSean Clinton Dix

PK- Jeremy Shelley
Punter- PJ Fitzgerald

PR- Marquis Maze
KR- Marquis Maze. A few notes: I put Jesse William at DE, because he played DE on one of the best defenses of all time last year (Chapman was NT). I put CJ as an OLB on my 1st team defense because I think he's versatile enough to play it, and he is too good not to be on the first team. I also have Cyrus at RT on 2nd team, because I couldn't put him above Andre or Carpenter (yet), but I couldn't put Drew Davis on the list and leave him off. I struggled with my 2nd team WR order, because I hated to leave off Hanks, but Norwood's performance in the NC game last year and his performance against LSU and ND this year. I also really hated leaving Glen Coffee off the list, but the 4 RB's on my list were pivotal in bringing home NC's, so I had to go that way.
 
Last edited:

bamamc1

Hall of Fame
Oct 24, 2011
5,401
3,898
187
Haleyville, AL
Awesome idea! Here's my 2 cents..with my 1st and 2nd string guys

QB - AJ McCarron - G. McElroy
RB - T. Richardson - G. Coffee
RB - M. Ingram - T. Yeldon
TE/HB - Travis McCall - Holla McGhee (I forget his real name)
WR - J. Jones - DJ Hall
WR - A. Cooper - Keith Brown
LT - Andre Smith - C.Kouandjio
LG - Chance Warmack - Barrett Jones
C - Barrett Jones - W. Vlachos
RG - Marlon Davis - A. Caldwell
RT - DJ Fluker - Mike Johnson
DE - Lorenzo Washington - Damien Square
DE - Marcel Dareus - B. Deadrick
DT - Terrance Cody - N. Gentry
LB - Eryk Anders - C. Upshaw
LB - Rolando McClain - N. Johnson
LB - Dont'a Hightower - C. Mosley
CB - Kareem Jackson - D. Kirkpatrick
CB - Dee Milliner - M. Johnson
CB - Javier Arenas - Javier Arenas (twice on purpose. No one has played that Star position better)
SS - Mark Barron - J. Woodall
FS - Rashad Johnson - R. Lester

PR/KR - Javier Arenas - Julio Jones
K - L. Tiffin - J. Shelley
P - PJ Fitzgerald - The current guy. Forgot his name
DJ Hll? Give me a break.
 

TrampLineman

Hall of Fame
Jul 21, 2010
7,287
6
57
Alabama
QB - A.J. McCarron - G. McElroy
RB - T. Richardson - E. Lacy
RB - M. Ingram - T.J. Yeldon
TE - C. Peek - M. Williams
FB/HB - Le'Ron McClain - B. Smelley
WR - J. Jones - D.J. Hall
WR - A. Cooper - Keith Brown
WR - M. Maze - D. Hanks
LT - A. Smith - J. Carpenter
LG - C. Warmack - M. Johnson
C - A. Caldwell - W. Vlachos
RG - B. Jones - A. Steen
RT - DJ Fluker - D. Davis
DE - W. Gilberry - B. Greenwood
DE - M. Dareus - D. Square
DT - T. Cody - J. Williams
LB - C. Upshaw - J. Harris
LB - Rolando McClain - N. Johnson
LB - Dont'a Hightower - C. Mosley
CB - S. Castille - D. Kirkpatrick
CB - D. Milliner - K. Jackson
CB - J. Arenas - M. Johnson
SS - M. Barron - J. Woodall
FS - R. Johnson - R. Lester

PR/KR - J. Arenas - M. Maze
K - L. Tiffin - J. Shelley
P - P.J. Fitzgerald - C. Mandell
 

GreatDanish

Hall of Fame
Nov 22, 2005
6,079
0
0
TN
DJ Hll? Give me a break.
He destroyed the career receiving yards record by almost 1,000 yards. He broke several other records. I think Hall is a pretty good choice, and at this point, could probably be justified winning a spot over Amari Cooper simply based on career accomplishments.

I could make an argument for others over Keith Brown, though.
 

bamabelle1991

All-American
Jan 1, 2009
4,040
179
87
South Alabama
Awesome idea! Here's my 2 cents..with my 1st and 2nd string guys

QB - AJ McCarron - G. McElroy
RB - T. Richardson - G. Coffee
RB - M. Ingram - T. Yeldon
TE/HB - Travis McCall - Holla McGhee (I forget his real name)
WR - J. Jones - DJ Hall
WR - A. Cooper - Keith Brown
LT - Andre Smith - C.Kouandjio
LG - Chance Warmack - Barrett Jones
C - Barrett Jones - W. Vlachos
RG - Marlon Davis - A. Caldwell
RT - DJ Fluker - Mike Johnson
DE - Lorenzo Washington - Damien Square
DE - Marcel Dareus - B. Deadrick
DT - Terrance Cody - N. Gentry
LB - Eryk Anders - C. Upshaw
LB - Rolando McClain - N. Johnson
LB - Dont'a Hightower - C. Mosley
CB - Kareem Jackson - D. Kirkpatrick
CB - Dee Milliner - M. Johnson
CB - Javier Arenas - Javier Arenas (twice on purpose. No one has played that Star position better)
SS - Mark Barron - J. Woodall
FS - Rashad Johnson - R. Lester

PR/KR - Javier Arenas - Julio Jones
K - L. Tiffin - J. Shelley
P - PJ Fitzgerald - The current guy. Forgot his name
Holla McGhee = Colin Peek. :)

And, I like your list.
 

Pugsley

BamaNation Citizen
Aug 27, 2012
58
0
0
Tuscaloosa, Alabama
I see the OP has been suspended, but don't see anything questionable. Did he do something and that something got deleted?

I don't post a lot, and I might be misreading the area where he has been suspended.

School me if I am wrong...
 

MVKTR2

1st Team
May 29, 2008
846
0
0
Offense
QB-AJ McCarron
Reserve QB-Greg McElroy

LT-Barrett Jones
LG-Chance Warmack
C -Barrett Jones
RG-Barrett Jones
RT-DJ Fluker
Reserve OL-Mike Johnson, Antoine Caldwell, Anthony Steen, Cyrus Kouandjio, Andre Smith

WR-Julio Jones
WR-Marquis Maze
WR-Amari Cooper
Reserve WR-Kenny Bell, Matt Caddell, Darius Hanks, Kevin Norwood

TE-Colin Peek
TE-Michael Williams
Reserve TE-Nick Walker, Travis McCall

RB-Trent Richardson
RB-Eddy Lacy
Reserve RB-Mark Ingram, TJ Yeldon, Jalston Fowler
*I suppose putting the hypeman trophy winner as a reserve might be a surprise, I simply think Lacy is better.
 

TidePride50

3rd Team
Jan 16, 2010
296
0
0
Richardson may be better than Ingram, but I think Ingram was more important to the '09 championship than Richardson was in '11 and Lacy in '12.


RTR '12!
 

RollTide1224

All-American
Feb 18, 2008
2,385
87
67
Spartanburg, SC
He destroyed the career receiving yards record by almost 1,000 yards. He broke several other records. I think Hall is a pretty good choice, and at this point, could probably be justified winning a spot over Amari Cooper simply based on career accomplishments.

I could make an argument for others over Keith Brown, though.
Go look at the career receiving records for bama. Cooper is 8 td's away from being the all time leader, he's also another 1,000 yard season away from being 4th all time. Assuming he doesn't have an injury there is no reason to think that he won't be the career record holder in all 3 by the time he is done the guy is that good.

It's interesting if you look at his game by game stats too. From the UT game onward he had 100 yards in every game except LSU, Miss st, and western carolina. He played one play in the LSU game and barely played against Western Carolina. Once he got worked into the offense he was producing at a ridiculous pace.

The first 6 games of the season he had 21 catches for 263 yards. The last 8 he had 38 catches for 737 even though he barely played in two of those games. The guy is a stud and is my favorite player on the team.
 

RollTide1224

All-American
Feb 18, 2008
2,385
87
67
Spartanburg, SC
Richardson may be better than Ingram, but I think Ingram was more important to the '09 championship than Richardson was in '11 and Lacy in '12.


RTR '12!
That's tough to say about Trent because all we had behind him was a gimpy Lacy and Fowler. With Mark we had Trent and Roy Upchurch. So the loss of Trent probably would have hurt more IMO. It's almost pointless to try and compare though, they have nearly identical stats one just won the Heisman and the other finished 3rd.
 

Latest threads

TideFans.shop : 2024 Madness!

TideFans.shop - Get YOUR Bama Gear HERE!”></a>
<br />

<!--/ END TideFans.shop & item link \-->
<p style= Purchases made through our TideFans.shop and Amazon.com links may result in a commission being paid to TideFans.