I posted this on Facebook earlier today:
I typically don't make serious posts on Facebook, but the weekend past was far from typical.
I am a conservative. I unambiguously reject and condemn the words and actions of neo-nazis and white supremacists in Charlottesville and anywhere else they may be. I do so, not because I'm a conservative, but because I'm an American. As any American should, I reject those who, by words and actions, themselves reject two foundational American principles: (1) that "all are created equal," and (2) that governments derive their just powers from the consent of the governed.
The words and actions of the so-called alt-right (which is to conservatism as a flea is to a dog) are completely incompatible with the American ideal. They obviously do not believe that all are created equal, and they do not appear to believe in government by consent, and therefore require condemnation and rejection from all Americans. Other extreme voices are no less to be rejected on a typical day - the violent antifa and marxist elements, for example, no less reject those two principles - but they have the relative virtue of not having inspired one of their members to kill anyone in the last 48 hours. So, I’ll set them aside; for now.
As a Southerner, let me add this: enough with the confederate idol worship. Southern pride, per se, is not incompatible with being American; but it’s nonsensical to be proud that your home state was a member of the confederacy, and also to be proud to be an American. If the confederacy had succeeded, and I’ll put this as gently as I can, WE SOUTHERNERS WOULDN’T BE AMERICANS. It’s at least as idiotic as people’s supporting Bernie Sanders’ policies using the euphemism “democratic socialism,” as if a vote of 51% of the people justifies their taking whatever they want from the other 49%. Such a tyranny of the majority is antithetical to the very idea of America, just as are neo-nazism and white supremacy.
Was Robert E. Lee a bad guy? Probably not, and given the nature of his surrender at Appomatox, we could use more gracious losers like him in the world today; but the fact remains that he and his compatriots waged war AGAINST OUR COUNTRY, at least in part to preserve an economic system built on enslaving those of another race. We should study and learn from them, but not revere them. Perhaps those advocating tearing down confederate monuments could be a little less strident given that they seem to be winning the argument (grace, after all, is no less called for in winning than in losing); but the fact remains that whatever reasonable claim to noble southern heritage might have been made, was forfeited when southern states rediscovered the confederate flag and began to fly it over their capitals at the very moment desegregation was imminent. Seen in that context, with the flag and confederate pining appropriated by segregationist elements, what reasonable “heritage” argument remains, other than a heritage that is segregationist, racist, and vile?
It should be enough to be American. It’s time, past time, to let the confederacy go, or else find someplace else to be whatever it is you prefer; just don't expect me to go with you...