Even though you admit Whisky's schedule is "so weak" you still think they should get in over an 11-1 Notre Dame who would have wins over USC, Miami, Stanford, and Michigan St? Now, I don't think any of those teams are great, but any one of them is a better win than anything Whisky has done. I do think a 12-1 UGA with a loss to Bama should go instead of Notre Dame since they beat them head-to-head, though.Any P5 team that is 12-0 going into its conference championship game should get in ahead of a one loss Notre Dame, IMO. But that isn't going to happen. Wisconsin is a great example. They have to win the B1GCG and be 13-0 to get in ahead of what would be an 11-1 Notre Dame team because their schedule is so weak.
But 12-0 should trump 11-1 every time in the P5.