I like the names that you have, but have always thought that it was too easy to make it to the "Hall of Fame" and "All American" status. Maybe drop out some of the middle levels. I mean, does anyone really deserve to make the "First Team" with 250 posts anymore? 15 years ago 250 posts was a ton. Today it is nothing. My boys probably post 250 times every day on various social media sites. I didn't even feel like I understood what was happening over here until I was about 1000 posts in.
But if you are just looking for additional levels, keeping the others as they are, what in football follows the same theme but is better than the Hall of Fame?
Maybe change Hall of Fame to Hall of Fame Nominee
Then Add Various Hall of Fame inductee levels like those mentioned before