Link: Gary Danielson Take On The SECCG

crimsonaudio · Dec 1, 2017

Tidewater said:
I guess you've never been to Bosnia. I saw people there turn off their own electricity in order to turn off the electricity of that other ethnic neighborhood across the way. Crazy.

Haha, nope.

And while I'm not the sharpest knife in the drawer, I think I could make the argument that I'm a good bit smarter than the people you referenced here...

If the Barn winning helps Bama get into the playoff then War Eagle! (For the record, I'd love another swing at those guys with healthier linebacking corps and away from the "magical" officiating of Jerdun Hair.)

Bingo. I can't imagine a fan not wanting what's best for Bama.

CrimsonNagus · Dec 1, 2017

Bamabuzzard said:
I don't want it like the NFL. I think a better rule would be to increase the yardage on the yardage. I'd like to see it be a spot foul up to 20-25 yards. Anything PI committed over 20-25 yards is an automatic 20-25 yard penalty from the LOS. I think that is severe enough.

20 yards is not severe enough if the PI prevents a TD. 20 yards is still a gift for the D if it occurs 40 yards downfield. Just my opinion but, I hate the current PI rule.

rgw · Dec 1, 2017

I think DPI should be a spot foul if it is going to be called so inconsistently by SEC officials but only 15 yards or spot if under 10 yards if it is called like Big-12 and Pac-12 officials.

Tidewater · Dec 1, 2017

B1GTide said:
They held on every play in the Iron Bowl. But Alabama and OSU used to employ those same tactics, so I really don't get too upset about it. The receivers need to be just as physical at the LOS. IMO, Alabama's receivers played soft in that game. They were not blocking for one another, and they were not creating separation with the DBs.

Amari Cooper was the best I have ever seen at not letting DBs disrupt the receiver's release up the field. Nobody could get a hand on him and that helped him get really open. A lot.

sanjosecrimson · Dec 1, 2017

Tidewater said:
Amari Cooper was the best I have ever seen at not letting DBs disrupt the receiver's release up the field. Nobody could get a hand on him and that helped him get really open. A lot.

Julio too. and he's still doing in the NFL!

gamersfuel · Dec 1, 2017

it probably wont ever happen in college because it would be called way too much due to when the competition is so much worse. they allow it in the NFL because a good bit of the defenders are good enough to not tackle you on every deep pass play

BamaBuc · Dec 1, 2017

What about just good ole spot foul with automatic 1st down...

3rd & 5 at own 35 - PI at own 41 - 1st & 10...(6 yd. Penalty)
2nd & 8 at the 50 - PI at 5 - 1st & Goal...(45 yd. Penalty)
1st & 10 at the 30 - PI at 23 - 1st & 10...(7 yd. Penalty)

Of course if either becomes a TD then penalty is declined and TD is awarded...
PI in end zone, if caught TD, if incomplete 1st & goal at the 5 or half the distance to the goal if ball was on or inside the 5...

If obvious PI and not called, the official gets ejected from the game!

JDCrimson · Dec 1, 2017

I would like to see it be called as an escalating penalty let the first infraction of the half be a 15-yard penalty and then subsequent and penalties of the same infraction increase for the remainder of the half and then reset the same process in the second half. Teams shouldn't be allowed to use the penalty in fraction as a defensive strategy it's not so much the yardage being inadequate. It is the frequency of the uncalled infraction.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G870A using Tapatalk

RT27 · Dec 1, 2017

I just want them to set the rule and enforce it. The calls are to inconsistent, either you can or cannot lay a hand on WR after 5 yards, period. Once the severity is called into play it is a ref decision. Either you can or cannot grab WR period. Time for clear rule, and consistent enforcement of whatever rule they decide on. It is time for a WR and a DB to know what is okay and what is not, in all games no matter what. Like a face mask, touch it it is 5 yards, grab and tug 15 yds. Lets do that , grab a WR 10 yds auto 1st down. Tackle him or really wrap him to avoid big long catch 25 yds auto 1st down. I like seeing the guys play, but holding a WR's arm and keeping him from being able to make a play should be stiff penalty. Play or cheat, but cheating should cost you. Letting a WR get tackled to avoid long TD and only getting 15 yds is no brainer for a defender if he gets burned. Get burned you should pay for it. Get better or get penalized big time.

bama_fan01 · Dec 2, 2017

ALA2262 said:
Exactly. If it takes my pulling for the barn in order for Bama to get into the CFP, then Bama will never be in the CFP again.

Agreed...I work in GA, and those folks are obnoxious for the most part. One of them asked me who I was pulling for, and I said no one. I told them that if the barn wins, it helps Bama's chances, and if uga wins, then the barn loses! It's a win/win situation in my book!

TUSCALOOSAHONOR · Dec 2, 2017

What was this thread about again?

editder · Dec 2, 2017

pigsinspace said:
What if they all lost. The chaos would be fun to watch. I will settle for two, though.

It would be interesting, but I don't believe there would be that much chaos. UGA and the U would both be in, and two among Bama, Clemson, and OSU should make up the other two slots. One team would be left out, which would be the same situation between Bama and OSU if OSU beats Wisconsin. Only difference would be that the team left out would be comparing their resume against two teams instead of one.

Search

Link: Gary Danielson Take On The SECCG

crimsonaudio

Administrator

CrimsonNagus

Hall of Fame

rgw

Suspended

Tidewater

Hall of Fame

sanjosecrimson

Hall of Fame

gamersfuel

All-American

BamaBuc

All-American

JDCrimson

Hall of Fame

RT27

All-American

bama_fan01

Hall of Fame

TUSCALOOSAHONOR

All-SEC

editder

All-SEC

New Posts

Latest threads

TideFans.shop - NEW Stuff!