Feels like we are arguing about the greatest play vs the most important game or something. Those are 2 different discussions IMO.
Agreed - if we are talking about most important, I would go with the first integrated play.Feels like we are arguing about the greatest play vs the most important game or something. Those are 2 different discussions IMO.
All right. I'll concede the point. What happened in 1926 has little to nothing to do with what motivates talented young men to go to Alabama to play football today. But that 17th national championship thing started with a first national championship 91 years ago.Sorry, but the whole "standing on the shoulders of giants" thing doesn't apply here unless the giant's name is Nick Saban.
Ask Notre Dame how worthless that stuff is when you are trying to win championships today.
IIRC, that game is considered the game that changed the perception of football in the South. The Alabama win gave Southern teams some validity in the eyes of the rest of the country.I'm not trying to be argumentative, but winning a first ever national championship does not exactly compare with winning a 17th (and a 5th in nine years).
Heck, Bama might have gone the route of Sewanee if not for that game.
Well done sir, well done.IIRC, that game is considered the game that changed the perception of football in the South. The Alabama win gave Southern teams some validity in the eyes of the rest of the country.
I don't see how the Tua pass can't be the answer to the question, though. If it's not, I have a submission - the play in 2005 when Drew Brees was injured while playing for the Chargers.
I've had over 4 months to think about it and jmo but Tua's "Dime in Overtime" is not just the greatest play in Alabama's history... but the greatest play in NCAA CFB history.Agree... this is as easy a choice as the poll for 'Would you Rather win a NC or Beat AU'...lol.
All the other plays are great plays for sure. But none of them were outright 'Game Winners'. They may have put us in a position to win or may have swung momentum or maybe this and maybe that....
TUA's play flat WON the National Championship.... via Walkoff Dagger like a stake straight through Dracula's Heart.
Wow. I had to think about that one for a momentIIRC, that game is considered the game that changed the perception of football in the South. The Alabama win gave Southern teams some validity in the eyes of the rest of the country.
I don't see how the Tua pass can't be the answer to the question, though. If it's not, I have a submission - the play in 2005 when Drew Brees was injured while playing for the Chargers.
See Post #144 at top of Pg. 12.I posted this in the Poll thread a few months back but it fits here too...
I've had over 4 months to think about it and jmo but Tua's "Dime in Overtime" is not just the greatest play in Alabama's history... but the greatest play in NCAA CFB history.
It absolutely 1000000000000% WON a National Championship in a bleak moment that looked to be a consecutive NCG loss. Just done.....Ballgame.....make room in the trophy case.
What other play is better? What other play guaranteed a National Title the moment it transpired? None that I can think of??
NiceIIRC, that game is considered the game that changed the perception of football in the South. The Alabama win gave Southern teams some validity in the eyes of the rest of the country.
I don't see how the Tua pass can't be the answer to the question, though. If it's not, I have a submission - the play in 2005 when Drew Brees was injured while playing for the Chargers.
Took me a moment also.Wow. I had to think about that one for a moment
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
OK, I give up. Can someone connect the dots for me?Took me a moment also.
OK, I give up. Can someone connect the dots for me?
Saban wanted Brees in Miami, but management went with Culpepper since Brees had suffered what many thought might be a career-ending injury. Of course, Brees' shoulder healed up nicely, and had the 'Fins done what CNS wanted, he likely would never have become the coach at Bama...OK, I give up. Can someone connect the dots for me?
Brees was the QB that Saban wanted at Miami. The Dolphins GM decided not to sign Brees because he was concerned about the recovery from said injury. This upset Saban, which was made worse when the QB he was left with failed while Brees went on the have great success.OK, I give up. Can someone connect the dots for me?
It is a less obvious answer than one might think when you are someone like me who really pays little attention to the NFL other than the Super Bowl, watching our Bama guys and hoping for their success, watching a game now and then just because nothing else is on.Saban wanted Brees in Miami, but management went with Culpepper since Brees had suffered what many thought might be a career-ending injury. Of course, Brees' shoulder healed up nicely, and had the 'Fins done what CNS wanted, he likely would never have become the coach at Bama...
Deshaun to Renfrow (ducks head). Actually I only found out recently that there was apparently one second on the clock after that play and they had to do a kickoff, I didn't know this because I turned the tv off after they caught the pass and haven't rewatched that particular portion of the game.I posted this in the Poll thread a few months back but it fits here too...
I've had over 4 months to think about it and jmo but Tua's "Dime in Overtime" is not just the greatest play in Alabama's history... but the greatest play in NCAA CFB history.
It absolutely 1000000000000% WON a National Championship in a bleak moment that looked to be a consecutive NCG loss. Just done.....Ballgame.....make room in the trophy case.
What other play is better? What other play guaranteed a National Title the moment it transpired? None that I can think of??
Every football season, I get up and thank God no one in Miami listened to Coach Saban and signed Daunte Culpepper instead of Brees.Nick Saban had to settle for playing Cleo Lemon at the end of 2006.
Cleo.
Lemon.
That same year Drew Brees led the NFL in passing yards.
Oh, what might have been...
He doesn't get hurt, he goes to Miami not NO...CNS never shows in Bama...
Saban wanted Brees in Miami, but management went with Culpepper since Brees had suffered what many thought might be a career-ending injury. Of course, Brees' shoulder healed up nicely, and had the 'Fins done what CNS wanted, he likely would never have become the coach at Bama...
Brees was the QB that Saban wanted at Miami. The Dolphins GM decided not to sign Brees because he was concerned about the recovery from said injury. This upset Saban, which was made worse when the QB he was left with failed while Brees went on the have great success.
Thanks, gang - always appreciate the info from the knowledgeable poster on this board :cool2:Nick Saban had to settle for playing Cleo Lemon at the end of 2006.
Cleo.
Lemon.
That same year Drew Brees led the NFL in passing yards.
Oh, what might have been...