I think Bowden is an all-time great coach, and it kills me that we could have had him for the offering, and instead took Bill Curry.
His record in the glory era was a bit inflated due to the overall weakness of the ACC. In his prime, he would have dominated the SEC....he just wouldn’t have had the ridiculous undefeated run that the weak opposition afforded.
Yes, he hung on too long. Yes, he was a bit lax on discipline. Yes, I think the aw-shucks public persona was overdone and not an entirely accurate depiction of his true personality. Those facts make him a flawed human being, and do not reflect on his abilities as a coach.
Flawed though he may be, he’s still an all-time Top 10 great coach.
This reminds me of a segment in the ESPN SEC Storied documentary about Steve Spurrier when Spurrier was recalling the year Fla St beat them in the regular season and they got the revenge in the national title game. One of the many points of contention Spurrier had with Bowden was Spurrier's belief that Bowden instructed his players to hit after the whistle. Spurrier said he confronted Bowden about it and Bowden told him they play to the echo of the whistle. Years later you still see Spurrier's angst about that when re-telling that story. I laughed out loud because that sounds just like something Bowden and his "aw shucks, pat you on the back while sticking a knife in you" approach. I also always love to see someone goad Spurrier.