Re: AJ McCarron Wins Grievance Against Bengals and Will Become Free Agent
despite the difficulty in finding a spot over his career, Sims was (besides Tua) arguably the best deep-ball thrower of the Saban era.No that's the point. Alabama runs a system that allows just about anybody to do that. That's why a converted RB who never even got to sniff the NFL at any position managed to break the single-season passing record at a school as storied as Alabama.
I'm not saying Greg is garbage, I just found him to be very underwhelming as a QB and to be frank I was quite worried AJ would be more of the same in his 1st year with the Tide - a year in which we won mostly on the strength of our defense and our running game - but he got consistently better the longer he was here to the point of developing into at least a consistent NFL backup.
Matt, we rarely disagree. I think I threw you with my initial comment, which was more hyperbolic and intended to be slightly outrageous, and in a thread already designed to somewhat scorch McElroy. But the truth is I don't see how anyone can watch the tape and think that Greg was anything but lucky to be on those teams as the starting QB. He has an excellent mind for the game! But none of the physical tools or other, non-mental intangibles, (quick twitch, consistent touch and accuracy) required to play it at a remarkable level.