Every school isn't a Hoover type located in a major metro that can actually recruit people away from other public or private schools. The majority of the public schools have very little capacity for that sort of movement.If anyone thinks public schools don't recruit they are kidding themselves.
I have no issue with private schools recruiting. This is BS for making them play this high above their enrollment.
This is only an issue because they are winning against bigger schools and they have their feelings hurt.
A lesser example would be to tell Alabama since you have won 5 of the last 9 Championships. Going forward you must play 12 Power 5 teams in the regular season.
I can think of one example in my lifetime where Fayette "recruited" a kid and it was mostly because Spencer Pennington got tired of being sacked a dozen times a game at Vernon so his parents moved from Lamar county to Fayette county.