If Georgia Doesn't Lose to L8U....

81usaf92 · Dec 3, 2018

B1GTide said:
You don't believe it, so just stop. UCF is 13-0.

UCF isn’t a P5. G5 won’t sniff a championship in a system that is designed to eliminate the possibility of a G5 in a NC.

B1GTide · Dec 3, 2018

81usaf92 said:
UCF isn’t a P5. G5 won’t sniff a championship in a system that is designed to eliminate the possibility of a G5 in a NC.

So, every P5 team with a 12-1 record is tied? Every 12-1 record by a P5 school is equal? I am calling bull on this one. You know better and you are pretending that you don't because it doesn't align with your agenda.

81usaf92 · Dec 3, 2018

B1GTide said:
So, every P5 team with a 12-1 record is tied? Every 12-1 record by a P5 school is equal? I am calling bull on this one. You know better and you are pretending that you don't because it doesn't align with your agenda.

2014 Ohio St had a lesser SOS by a mile than TCU, and a comparable one to Baylor. Tell me the true difference of the two.

B1GTide · Dec 3, 2018

81usaf92 said:
2014 Ohio St had a lesser SOS by a mile than TCU, and a comparable one to Baylor. Tell me the true difference of the two.

Forget some other year - talk about this year. If Georgia had beat LSU and there were 3 teams at 12-1, they would first examine those 12-1 schedules and results. One would stand out as significantly better. I wonder which. :conf3:

I'm not going round with you on this anymore. You know better.

81usaf92 · Dec 3, 2018

B1GTide said:
Forget some other year - talk about this year. If Georgia had beat LSU and there were 3 teams at 12-1, they would first examine those 12-1 schedules and results. One would stand out as significantly better. I wonder which. :conf3:

I'm not going round with you on this anymore. You know better.

Agree to disagree. But I’m fairly confident that they wouldn’t A) have a direct rematch and 2) create a situation which calls for a playoff expansion.

Georgia in this scenario and in real life had their chance and deserves to be in the Sugar Bowl. In both 2016 and 2017 Ohio St and Alabama were the only options in a time in which other conferences eliminated themselves.

This has never been about finding the 4 BEST Teams. This has been about finding most DESERVING and eliminating the G5.

B1GTide · Dec 3, 2018

81usaf92 said:
Agree to disagree.

:cheers2:

bamacon · Dec 3, 2018

Just like if Ohio St. hadn’t had its doors blown off by Purdue it’s in. Two losses is just tough period but a 20 pointer is too tough when the committee has options.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

CoachInWaiting · Dec 4, 2018

81usaf92 said:
Had they not lost to LSU the rankings going into Saturday would’ve looked like this.

1. UA
2 UGA
3. Clemson
4. ND
5. Oklahoma
6. TOSU

With Saturday’s result we know these rankings for sure

1. UA
2. Clemson
3. ND

UGA would still be in a tiebreaker with OU, and the top criteria point of the CFP is “conference champion”. It’s one reason I’ve never bought into Bama was in regardless.

If that was the ranking pre-SECCG, I think the committee would have merely flipped UGA and Clemson. No rematch in the semifinals, only in the final if both Alabama and UGA won their semi. As for UCF, if they could somehow manage to go 24-0 in a season by playing twice a week, it still wouldn't matter.

bamaga · Dec 4, 2018

CoachInWaiting said:
....are they in the CFP? I think maybe they are. Staying that close to Alabama and losing in the fashion they did, I think it was the L8U loss that did them in. Without that loss, they may have entered the SECCG at #2 or #3, giving the committee the chance to drop them to #4. Hard to say, as a rematch of the last game that both teams played would be a bitter pill for many on the committee to swallow. Last year was tough enough for them, but at least the 2 teams from the same conference had not already played.

. They almost made it with a 20 point blowout loss , so I would say yes.

bamaga · Dec 4, 2018

81usaf92 said:
Had they not lost to LSU the rankings going into Saturday would’ve looked like this.

1. UA
2 UGA
3. Clemson
4. ND
5. Oklahoma
6. TOSU

With Saturday’s result we know these rankings for sure

1. UA
2. Clemson
3. ND

UGA would still be in a tiebreaker with OU, and the top criteria point of the CFP is “conference champion”. It’s one reason I’ve never bought into Bama was in regardless.

Georgia is unequivocally better than Oklahoma , so no tie breaker. That phrase , unequivocally better, is the key .

81usaf92 · Dec 4, 2018

bamaga said:
Georgia is unequivocally better than Oklahoma , so no tie breaker. That phrase , unequivocally better, is the key .

If y’all really want to buy into this “4 best teams” mantra then go ahead. I have 5 years that proves otherwise.

B1GTide · Dec 4, 2018

81usaf92 said:
If y’all really want to buy into this “4 best teams” mantra then go ahead. I have 5 years that proves otherwise.

In your opinion. We just disagree.

Also, You can't "prove" anything unless you have someone who is in that room willing to publicly say that they made the decisions for reasons other than an effort to put in the 4 best teams.

bamaga · Dec 4, 2018

81usaf92 said:
If y’all really want to buy into this “4 best teams” mantra then go ahead. I have 5 years that proves otherwise.

I think this year is the first year of the most deserving.

81usaf92 · Dec 4, 2018

B1GTide said:
In your opinion. We just disagree.

Also, You can't "prove" anything unless you have someone who is in that room willing to publicly say that they made the decisions for reasons other than an effort to put in the 4 best teams.

Then where are the Bullfrauds now??? 5th going to the Sugar Bowl. This is and never has been about the 4 best teams. If that was the case ND wouldn’t be in right now.

81usaf92 · Dec 4, 2018

bamaga said:
I think this year is the first year of the most deserving.

2015-18 have all the “most deserving”. 2014 is the only time they ever made a controversial decision and they thanked their lucky stars Ohio St won it because TCU totally dismantled Ole Miss a day before the Sugar Bowl.

DawgByte · Dec 5, 2018

CoachInWaiting said:
....are they in the CFP? I think maybe they are. Staying that close to Alabama and losing in the fashion they did, I think it was the L8U loss that did them in. Without that loss, they may have entered the SECCG at #2 or #3, giving the committee the chance to drop them to #4. Hard to say, as a rematch of the last game that both teams played would be a bitter pill for many on the committee to swallow. Last year was tough enough for them, but at least the 2 teams from the same conference had not already played.

I agree. The fact the committee placed them between OU and Tosu confirms they would have been placed in the Top 4. We're a different team than the one that played against LSU. I'd love another shot at the Tigers, because I think we'd win. But hey, I wear rose colored glasses.

BamaMoon · Dec 5, 2018

Only question for me would Georgia (without the LSU loss) have been at 3 or 4.

I think to avoid a rematch in the semis they put ND at 4. We'd probably get a rematch with Georgia in the finals.

DawgByte · Dec 5, 2018

BamaMoon said:
Only question for me would Georgia (without the LSU loss) have been at 3 or 4.

I think to avoid a rematch in the semis they put ND at 4. We'd probably get a rematch with Georgia in the finals.

Agree, without the LSU loss they would have put UGA at #3 and ND at #4.

RammerJammer14 · Dec 5, 2018

If Tua doesn’t roll his ankle on the first offensive series, Georgia doesn’t even have a close SECCG loss to lean on.

If Georgia Doesn't Lose to L8U....

TideFans Legend

TideFans Legend

TideFans Legend

TideFans Legend

TideFans Legend

TideFans Legend

Hall of Fame

3rd Team

Hall of Fame

Hall of Fame

TideFans Legend

TideFans Legend

Hall of Fame

TideFans Legend

TideFans Legend

1st Team

Hall of Fame

1st Team

Hall of Fame

TideFans.shop - NEW Stuff!