Players leaving early for the draft

JustNeedMe81 · Jan 9, 2019

B1GTide said:
At least Thompson is still thinking about it, but he is a 1st rounder. Alabama could benefit from his return more than anyone else on your defense (other than Q, who HAS to go).

JMO, but if Mack goes, you might actually be better off next year. He has a world of talent, but he can't turn it into consistent play. Kaho is going to be a star.

This!

Sent from my SM-G965U using Tapatalk

Tidewater · Jan 9, 2019

BamaTilDeath said:
Thompson seemed confident and reacted with a burst to the ball in '17 and specifically against Louisville game in' 18.

Not to bash a player, but my non-Alabama fan friend I watched the game with was more than a little exasperated by Thompson peaking into the back field as a wideout streaked past him towards the end zone. He said, "you need to be as deep as the deepest opposing player. You are the last line of defense. It is in your job title."

Thompson is a physically talented player, but he would be well-served if he stopped peaking into the backfield. His eyes mislead him sometimes.

CoachJeff · Jan 9, 2019

Tidewater said:
Not to bash a player, but my non-Alabama fan friend I watched the game with was more than a little exasperated by Thompson peaking into the back field as a wideout streaked past him towards the end zone. He said, "you need to be as deep as the deepest opposing player. You are the last line of defense. It is in your job title."

Thompson is a physically talented player, but he would be well-served if he stopped peaking into the backfield. His eyes mislead him sometimes.

His misread on the 3rd and 12 early in the game really set the tone and not in a good way.

He seemed to regress as the season went on.

B1GTide · Jan 9, 2019

CoachJeff said:
His misread on the 3rd and 12 early in the game really set the tone and not in a good way.

He seemed to regress as the season went on.

I think that both he and Mack tried to play the role of hero too often in this defense, putting themselves out of position. But Thompson had a number of monster games. I can see him returning to form. I am just not as sure about Mack, and Kaho makes it easier to see him go if that is his choice. You don't really have anyone ready to step into Thompson's shoes.

RTR91 · Jan 9, 2019

Mack’s mom told the Montgomery Advertiser in December he would be coming back.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

RTR91 · Jan 9, 2019

Some rumblings an offensive player might return that would surprise some folks.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

BamaFlum · Jan 9, 2019

RTR91 said:
Some rumblings an offensive player might return that would surprise some folks.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Irv or JJ? Someone else? Not sure who else would be surprising.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

B1GTide · Jan 9, 2019

RTR91 said:
Some rumblings an offensive player might return that would surprise some folks.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Jonah or Irv?

RTR91 · Jan 9, 2019

B1GTide said:
Jonah or Irv?

Irv

Looks like Murray is going to test the NFL waters...

https://www.sfgate.com/athletics/article/A-s-draftee-Kyler-Murray-will-not-play-both-13521091.php

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

UAllday · Jan 9, 2019

I remember seeing preseason that Jonah was really looking to play out his eligibility. Him or Irv is my guess, slightly favoring Jonah. Jacobs with two kids now, almost has to go.

Texas_tide · Jan 9, 2019

Terrell Lewis and Raekwon and Diggs really help the defense.
One more year of Mack would benefit him.

deliveryman35 · Jan 9, 2019

BamaTilDeath said:
Davis, Thompson, & Wilson didn't seem to progress this season. Davis seemed capable of getting pressure on a QB. I can't remember a game this year where he had a solo sack. Thompson seemed confident and reacted with a burst to the ball in '17 and specifically against Louisville game in' 18. In '16 and '17 seasons, Wilson definitely made more plays with Foster & Hamilton beside him at LB. Now, he seemed to be thinking and reacting late and making false steps toward the ball. To me, their lack of progression is a reflection of the position coaches and DC not putting them in positions to succeed. I don't know what the answer is to fix this issue, but I have confidence in Coach Saban to right the ship.

Sent from my SM-N950U using Tapatalk

Wilson regressed imo. With what we have coming in and competition, he will need to work his butt off in spring/fall camp to maintain his position on the depth chart. He vastly underachieved this year and it showed all season long.

BJ4TIDE · Jan 9, 2019

There was one point, after the game, where a camera focused on Jonah Williams. The look on his face made me have a feeling that he was contemplating coming back. THAT would be awesome, but any of the big contributors would be a welcome return next year.

BAMAVILLE · Jan 9, 2019

RTR91 said:
Irv

Looks like Murray is going to test the NFL waters...

https://www.sfgate.com/athletics/article/A-s-draftee-Kyler-Murray-will-not-play-both-13521091.php

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Having Irv back would be huge. I'm thinking more of the players that can declare early are not happy with how the season ended and want to make another run at it. It will be good to get back whoever we can because that means we will have more seniors to add to the leadership thats focused on winning a championship. But I know the staff will encourage them to make the best decision possible, especially if they can go early in the draft.

BamaTilDeath · Jan 10, 2019

BJ4TIDE said:
There was one point, after the game, where a camera focused on Jonah Williams. The look on his face made me have a feeling that he was contemplating coming back. THAT would be awesome, but any of the big contributors would be a welcome return next year.

I know one play doesn't define a player's college football career, but there's a play against Clemson were Jonah gets bull rushed and he lands on his back. I think Tua is sacked on the play by 2 defenders. That play shocked me because Jonah usually uses great technique, but that's the first time I've seen him placed on his back.

Sent from my SM-N950U using Tapatalk

Toddrn · Jan 10, 2019

It looked like he came off the line off balance or got stepped on. That play was messed up from the get go.

BamaTilDeath said:
I know one play doesn't define a player's college football career, but there's a play against Clemson were Jonah gets bull rushed and he lands on his back. I think Tua is sacked on the play by 2 defenders. That play shocked me because Jonah usually uses great technique, but that's the first time I've seen him placed on his back.

Sent from my SM-N950U using Tapatalk

Bama9001 · Jan 10, 2019

I've seen Irv described as a devastating blocker and as a liability as a blocker. Not sure which is true but if the latter that would be a really good reason to return. The NFL doesn't have much need for TEs that aren't good blockers. Come back, bulk up some more, become a better blocker, and then go to the NFL as a higher draft pick.

Experts, is he a good blocker or not?

Chechem · Jan 10, 2019

BamaTilDeath said:
I know one play doesn't define a player's college football career, but there's a play against Clemson were Jonah gets bull rushed and he lands on his back. I think Tua is sacked on the play by 2 defenders. That play shocked me because Jonah usually uses great technique, but that's the first time I've seen him placed on his back.

As Toddrn said, Jonah was off balance. Tua moved to his left while Jonah was blocking for the pocket, which benefited the rusher. It wasn't a simple case of bad technique or overpowering by the D line.

Evil Crimson Dragon · Jan 10, 2019

Texas_tide said:
Terrell Lewis and Raekwon and Diggs really help the defense.
One more year of Mack would benefit him.

Those three would definitely help...... especially Lewis

TAKEPRIDE22 · Jan 10, 2019

I think Mack should return, but just my opinion. He struggled with his reads and you can see the defense moving and looking lost on quite a few plays. Mack has the physical ability, but just need to work more on getting the defense in the right alignment.

Players leaving early for the draft

Hall of Fame

Hall of Fame

Suspended

TideFans Legend

Super Moderator

Super Moderator

Hall of Fame

TideFans Legend

Super Moderator

3rd Team

Scout Team

Hall of Fame

All-SEC

Moderator (FB,BB,REC)

Scout Team

All-American

1st Team

Scout Team

Hall of Fame

2nd Team

TideFans.shop - NEW Stuff!