March 31, 1995
Strike Day 231
SOTOMAYOR SUSPENDS STRIKE SO STARS CAN START SEASON
PLAY BALL!
In the end it all came down to a Latina raised three miles from Yankee Stadium in the Bronx to end the most costly, gut-wrenching, and damaging strike in the history of American sports, a woman who in only fifteen minutes managed to fix (or at least duct tape) something a bunch of men have been unable to resolve for nearly eight months. And she was nothing short of dazzling in her performance, joking after her ruling that she would "have liked more time to practice my swing." In only four days, NY District Judge Sonia Sotomayor, a judge appointed to the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York by President George H.W. Bush, mastered the arguments and occurences of the strike, figured her action might even end it since it is well-known the principals are already very close to agreement, and in all probability saved the baseball owners from their stubborness yet again by making it virtually impossible for them to open the season this weekend unless the owners have real appetite for corporate suicide.
"I am ruling today because the issue before me is critical to all the participants who are here and to the public. I also realize that waiting serves no useful purpose." With those words, Sotomayor issued the challenge for the two sides to come to some sort of agreement, concluding with, "Even though opening day is just days away, the parties still have time to salvage it."
The owners, who have managed to ignore the fans, the players, the press, and reality will not be able to ignore the orders of a federal judge. Of course, the owners do have a couple of options, but these are likely little more than threats that only the truly delusional would seek to invoke. The first option is that they may lock out the players and proceed with replacements, but this would snatch defeat from the jaws of, well, defeat. The owners have been given an out so as to not use the replacement players, and it doesn't appear they have the votes to impose a lockout. That leaves another alternative that is only slightly more appealing than the lockout, to appeal Sotomayor's ruling and hope it is overturned. But not only is such a strategy an enormous gamble, it could be a costly one as well. If the owners are found to have violated federal labor laws - and the judgment from Sotomayor suggests that they would probably lose such a case - then the owners could be assessed fines of $5 million PER DAY of the strike that has already gone on for 230 days. Even the richest owners cannot afford an additional billion-dollar loss, although one or two might try to persuade the others that this is a winnable case.
The owners will decide their course of action Saturday, April 2, which will protect them from making much news for surrendering given the eyes of the country will likely be on the NCAA men's basketball Final Four that day.
Strike Day 231
SOTOMAYOR SUSPENDS STRIKE SO STARS CAN START SEASON
PLAY BALL!
In the end it all came down to a Latina raised three miles from Yankee Stadium in the Bronx to end the most costly, gut-wrenching, and damaging strike in the history of American sports, a woman who in only fifteen minutes managed to fix (or at least duct tape) something a bunch of men have been unable to resolve for nearly eight months. And she was nothing short of dazzling in her performance, joking after her ruling that she would "have liked more time to practice my swing." In only four days, NY District Judge Sonia Sotomayor, a judge appointed to the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York by President George H.W. Bush, mastered the arguments and occurences of the strike, figured her action might even end it since it is well-known the principals are already very close to agreement, and in all probability saved the baseball owners from their stubborness yet again by making it virtually impossible for them to open the season this weekend unless the owners have real appetite for corporate suicide.
"I am ruling today because the issue before me is critical to all the participants who are here and to the public. I also realize that waiting serves no useful purpose." With those words, Sotomayor issued the challenge for the two sides to come to some sort of agreement, concluding with, "Even though opening day is just days away, the parties still have time to salvage it."
The owners, who have managed to ignore the fans, the players, the press, and reality will not be able to ignore the orders of a federal judge. Of course, the owners do have a couple of options, but these are likely little more than threats that only the truly delusional would seek to invoke. The first option is that they may lock out the players and proceed with replacements, but this would snatch defeat from the jaws of, well, defeat. The owners have been given an out so as to not use the replacement players, and it doesn't appear they have the votes to impose a lockout. That leaves another alternative that is only slightly more appealing than the lockout, to appeal Sotomayor's ruling and hope it is overturned. But not only is such a strategy an enormous gamble, it could be a costly one as well. If the owners are found to have violated federal labor laws - and the judgment from Sotomayor suggests that they would probably lose such a case - then the owners could be assessed fines of $5 million PER DAY of the strike that has already gone on for 230 days. Even the richest owners cannot afford an additional billion-dollar loss, although one or two might try to persuade the others that this is a winnable case.
The owners will decide their course of action Saturday, April 2, which will protect them from making much news for surrendering given the eyes of the country will likely be on the NCAA men's basketball Final Four that day.