Alabama's best played game in the Nick Saban era?

4Q Basket Case

FB|BB Moderator
Staff member
Nov 8, 2004
10,345
15,352
337
Tuscaloosa
I haven't seen this one mentioned, but the 2013 BCS NCG against Notre Dame gets my vote. It was total domination from start to finish. The best half is either the 2018 semifinal against OU or the 2008 UGA game.
That’s mine as well.

Mrs. Basket Case and I were there. Our seats were on the aisle between the ND and Alabama sections. Contrary to ND’s claimed class, we caught a lot of mouthiness on the way in just walking to our seats without any ostentationsness whatsoever.

Then we scored 3 TDs on our first three possessions. I don’t remember what the halftime score was, but the Irish were smoked and they knew it.

On his way back to his seat after halftime, one of the mouthy guys passed me. He was wearing a Kelly green shirt saying ”Catholics vs. Cousins,” with what would be classified as a demeaning cartoon if it were depicting anybody other than Deep South rural people.

I just looked up and said, without rancor of any sort, “Nice shirt. Does that include made-up cousins?” The obvious reference was to Manti Te’o, whose fictitious girlfriend was just then coming out. His reaction indicated that he really didn’t want to be wearing that shirt at that moment.

Aside from winning the NC in convincing fashion, my favorite part of that game was AJ McCarron and Barrett Jones getting into it on the last possession. What an absolutely driven team. Sweet memories.
 

PA Tide Fan

All-American
Dec 11, 2014
4,953
3,984
187
Lancaster, PA
I'll give another vote for the 2013 NCG against ND as well. Certainly the 2012 NCG with LSU was the best defensive performance in the Saban era holding LSU to under 100 yards of total offense. To my knowledge that was the only time that happened in a NCG. Scoring 52 on Ohio State in the 2021 NCG was certainly a fine offensive performance, but going back to 2013 Alabama and Notre Dame were ranked #1 and #2 in scoring defense that season and we scored 42 on them and the game was 35-0 late in the 3rd quarter before ND finally scored so I'd say that was the game both offense and defense were outstanding.
 

Tidelines

All-American
Oct 19, 2022
2,505
4,108
187
Had to be 2013 championship game verses ND. Even Brian Kelley agreed ( in the halftime interview.)
 

Krymsonman

Hall of Fame
Sep 1, 2009
7,880
6,113
187
River Ridge, LA
The nominees:
2008 vs Georgia (blackout game)
2009 SECCG vs Florida
2012 BCSNCG vs LSU
2015 vs Georgia (post-Ole Miss hangover)
2015 vs LSU
2015 CFP vs Michigan St
2021 SECCG vs Georgia

My vote is undecided but between the 2012 LSU national title game and the 2021 UGA game.
I'll go with 2012 NC vs LSU as it was almost a perfect game. (settled for too many FG's though)
Then 2021 SECCG vs Georgia. Great game, and no one expected BAMA to win.
Then I'll throw in NC vs Notre Dame. It was just a joy to watch us crush ND.
 

AWRTR

All-American
Oct 18, 2022
3,039
4,500
187
Don't know if I get a vote, but I'm voting anyway.

2018 SEC Championship game Vs Georgia 35-28.

I know it wasn't a championship year but that's the most emotional I (as an outsider looking in) has been watching a Bama game, the whole Jalen Hurts redemption arc thing just pushed me over an edge, literally teared up watching that live.
I just got something in my eye that day.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Go Bama and RWBTide

cbi1972

Hall of Fame
Nov 8, 2005
18,713
2,629
182
52
Birmingham, AL
I think on the next play they lost yards and got thrown back across mid-field.
They had no plays starting in Alabama territory that gained yards.

They made it from the 50 to the Alabama 32 on a QB rush.

Then they proceeded to lose 3 yards, lose 5 more on a false start, and throw two incomplete passes. Then they lost a fumble on 4th down.

They would have one more possession in which they lost 4 yards on three plays
 

saturdaysarebet

3rd Team
Jul 26, 2018
272
69
52
I haven't seen this one mentioned, but the 2013 BCS NCG against Notre Dame gets my vote. It was total domination from start to finish. The best half is either the 2018 semifinal against OU or the 2008 UGA game.
I had thought of that Notre Dame game but even though the Irish were undefeated, they had three close games which left me wondering how good were they really.
 
Last edited:

Amazon Deals for TideFans!

YouTheFan Alabama Desk Pad

Purchases may result in a commission being paid to TideFans.

Latest threads