Jalen Milroe is now the starter going forward.

[Bamaingeorgia81]

Why do you assume he hates Milroe? I don't know of anyone on here that hates him. Some of us just don't think he's the answer.

Does anyone really think he is 'the answer'? I don't see how they could.....

I agree with starting him saturday, but he's as much of an 'answer' as shaq is a teams technical free throw shooter.

 

[westide]

He throws a good deep ball. Throw deep often...if the OL can protect.

 

[TexasBama]

Regardless of how this goes, there is one silver lining. Basketball season starts November 6th.

 

[colbysullivan]

Alabama lost that game. You win or lose as a team. How can you consider yourself to be a Tide fan and hate some of its players?

Where did I say I hated him? I can root for him to succeed and still acknowledge the reality that he’s not a QB.

 

[MikeInBama]

I keep wishing for Blake Sims year for Milroe but we don’t have Kiffin calling plays 🤷‍♂️

 

[colbysullivan]

I keep wishing for Blake Sims year for Milroe but we don’t have Kiffin calling plays 🤷‍♂️

Or Amari Cooper

 

[teamplayer]

I'm no defensive expert, but wouldn't zone with two deep safeties seem the better plan for someone like Miloroe?

Two deep safeties will hurt his deep ball and he doesn't see underneath coverage which led to his two terrible INTs.

I'd put my best athlete on defense as a spy.

I agree. I would want my guys in
zone so they can see the QB's eyes because he stares right where he will throw the ball.

 

[MikeInBama]

Or Amari Cooper

Or Kenyan Drake

 

[Cruloc]

Or Kenyan Drake

Yep, we don't have the horses we had on that 2015 team. That team wasn't soft, they didn't have anxiety. They would blow the doors off this 2023 team.

 

[Tenntiderman]

no....they were both really bad(again, qbr scores of 15 and 20 for the game). And neither made more than 2 plus plays each. I give the edge to Simspon because he did make the one nice throw to Dippre.

All I'm saying is that Buchners performance would appear more correctable. After all, he possibly couldn't be that inacurrate all the time(or could he?)

That said, I don't really want either anywhere near a football field for us lol.....

Said this before...I might agree had Simpson been able to stand up and actually READ the field before getting blasted. Blows my mind that you can't see this. How is Simpson going to read a Defense when he has 3 D players in his face a split second after catching low or high fastballs? Same with JM. Buchner had problems at ND. Simpson doesn't deserve the critcism. I saw the game too. There is a narrative against that young man that I suspect has nothing to do with football. He got ZERO protection after the snap. Buchner got very little as well, but I did see some nerves I think. The boy is just not up to this level I think, and Simpson may not be Ken Stabler himself, but he got us on the board with very little experience and no protection...but to say he shouldn't play is over the top.

 

[Tenntiderman]

Yep. Avalos was literally the last QB standing.

Wasn't Avalos recruited for his skill in running the Triple Option, which Franchione really liked to use? Seems like he was good at that style in HS.

 

[Tenntiderman]

I do agree with two things Josh Pate said. 1) this is quite possibly THE pivotal game of the season for this team. If, by some rhyme or reason, things click, they come together as team and win this game, it can get them rolling. If they don’t, there could be 2-3 other losses on the schedule. 2) Based on the performances we’ve seen thus far, I haven’t a clue what this game will look like. I wouldn’t bet my worst enemy’s money on this game.

This team is exactly how Churchill described the former Soviet Union: it is “a riddle, wrapped in a mystery, inside an enigma”.

Not a lot has changed across the pond since Winston's wisdom. Reading on that now.

 

[mlh]

To be fair to Avalos, he was a very good QB in high school. Watch some of his films - Michael Vick kind of plays - but that was against HS talent. He was in over his head playing in the SEC.

 

[bamacon]

As long as the offensive line stinks as bad as this line stinks, it doesn't matter who plays QB.

Might as well put someone back there who can scoot his booty outta there in a hurry.

 

[bamacon]

He wasn't great at Notre Dame, but what he did in Tampa Saturday made him look like an 8th grader trying to play in the NFL.

No it looked like me and my family when we play our pickup game at Thanksgiving

 

[bamacon]

Some of you think Saban is being held hostage or something and that's just wild to me.

Agreed. He’d already be on the set at Gameday.

 

[bamacon]

I think it’s time for the REC to get to the bottom of this…

 

[BamaInCummingGA]

Read his posts.

I have. Nowhere does he indicate he hates anyone.
Show me a post where he says he hates someone.
Don't call people out like this just because they don't agree with you.

 

[Slowpoke Catracho]

 

[JDCrimson]

I went back and watched the Texas highlights, here are my observations...

1. Milroe gives us the best chance to win if we need offense, which will likely be the case against Ole Miss.
2. Milroe also presents our highest risk of losing due to turnover risk.
3. Milroe is a zero read QB. He is going to throw to the primary WR and most likely not see the coverage in the area, hence the zero read.
4. Milroe will be a major risk in the red zone if we are behind the chains.
5. Milroe can flip the field with one broken containment.

Honestly, I would play both Milroe and Simpson in the game based on situation sort of like Spurrier did. Let Milroe drive to the red zone, then let Simpson play ball control red zone offense. This approach allows both QBs to get better with game action.