Not arguing for Frost - but Saban sells the program. We're still getting tons of great defensive players despite having a DC that isn't a household name and lacking the ferocious defense we're accustomed to.
FTR, with Frost as OC for Oregon, Mariota won the Heisman and they made it to the NC game.
That was 2014, defenses have caught up a little, and our most successful quarterback in the NFL is a pocket passer. Our most successful running backs in the nfl were feature backs in college, and Julio was the featured wideout in his tenure. Would he really bring anything to the system that someone else couldn’t? He runs the offense at Nebraska. He’s failed miserably to upgrade even one skilled position there. I think BoB and Frost would be similar hires in that when given the keys to a Ferrari offense they would drove it like they owned it, never really showcasing its ability, whereas Sark and Kiffin drove it like they stole it and made the nightly news.
The more I sit here and think about it, I’m beginning to lean towards Marrone because the more I watch the more I realize that it doesn’t matter what play you call if the defenders are in the backfield on a two Mississippi count and linemen are looking left when a defender is running by their right shoulder. The line has several issues: coaching, learning, apparent missed recruiting analysis, and a leader for them to get behind.
Glad they aren’t asking me to make the decisions, and super glad I’m not the one to have to make them.