NFL Rookie Debut

[Cleburne]

GMAC started slow but, finished big. He got more comfortable as the game went on. He gets my vote.

 

[Bama1993]

i'm disappointed that we have so many Bama homers when it comes to these type questions. As hard as it might seem, let's try and take off the crimson glasses for once and give credit where credit is due. Ryan Mallett had the most impressive debut among rookies, not Julio or Ingram.

Since more than a couple of you will probably argue this statement, let's do it this way....
Player A...12/19 164 yards, 1 TD
Player B...2 rec 43 yards, 1 rush 12 yards

there, now who would you vote for? yeah, i thought so...

Agreed. After I posted this, i realized I should've included Mallett and Reggie Cobb.

 

[crmsntd91]

Easily the most impressive rookie to me through these first 2 preseason games is Stevan Ridley. Guy looks like a stud in the backfield. Just my opinion though!

 

[TiderJack]

Falcons and Julio on Fox tonight at least in the B'ham market.

 

[Florida Tom]

GMAC started slow but, finished big. He got more comfortable as the game went on. He gets my vote.

This^^^^^^