Toggle sidebar

JessN: Potential transfer portal targets as Bama remakes its roster

bamadwain said:
I believe if we get him and Carver from Mississippi State I believe we are done at wr, Williams is the alpha dog and we don't need someone coming in who wants to be the man, we need guys who will accept their roles and a fit for CKD offense
Click to expand...

Remember we once had Calvin Ridley, Devonta Smith, Jerry Jeudy and Henry Ruggs on the roster at the same time, with Foster and Sims as well.

The next year it was Smith, Jeudy, Ruggs. Lost a Ridley, gained a Waddle.

Then we had those 4, plus Metchie.

teams who spread the ball around don't have to have a single Alpha cause everyone's getting their touches. While we might never have that depth of talent we had for that run, with the right focus and approach we should definitely have room for more than just 1-2 top level guys to produce.
 
  • Like
  • Emphasis!
Reactions: REBELZED, CarolinaCrimson, Con and 8 others
gtgilbert said:
Remember we once had Calvin Ridley, Devonta Smith, Jerry Jeudy and Henry Ruggs on the roster at the same time, with Foster and Sims as well.

The next year it was Smith, Jeudy, Ruggs. Lost a Ridley, gained a Waddle.

Then we had those 4, plus Metchie.

teams who spread the ball around don't have to have a single Alpha cause everyone's getting their touches. While we might never have that depth of talent we had for that run, with the right focus and approach we should definitely have room for more than just 1-2 top level guys to produce.
Click to expand...

Having room does not mean that we will have the money.
Top WRs cost $$$$ NIL, and it is not clear how many we can afford.
 
gtgilbert said:
Remember we once had Calvin Ridley, Devonta Smith, Jerry Jeudy and Henry Ruggs on the roster at the same time, with Foster and Sims as well.

The next year it was Smith, Jeudy, Ruggs. Lost a Ridley, gained a Waddle.

Then we had those 4, plus Metchie.

teams who spread the ball around don't have to have a single Alpha cause everyone's getting their touches. While we might never have that depth of talent we had for that run, with the right focus and approach we should definitely have room for more than just 1-2 top level guys to produce.
Click to expand...
CKD was able to put up unreal numbers with Rome Odunze, Ja’Lynn Polk, and Jalen McMillan. That group is nothing to wave a stick at but I think we can acquire a similar corps.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rocky Mtn Bob and TiderJack
cdub55 said:
CKD was able to put up unreal numbers with Rome Odunze, Ja’Lynn Polk, and Jalen McMillan. That group is nothing to wave a stick at but I think we can acquire a similar corps.
Click to expand...

His big numbers were not against SEC defenses. There is a difference.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bamaclimber
some_al_fan said:
His big numbers were not against SEC defenses. There is a difference.
Click to expand...
Penix threw for 430 yards in a 37-31 win over Texas. Odunze caught a pedestrian 125 yards and Polk was able to get a measly 122 yards. That offense would have fared just fine in the SEC last year...
 
cdub55 said:
Penix threw for 430 yards in a 37-31 win over Texas. Odunze caught a pedestrian 125 yards and Polk was able to get a measly 122 yards. That offense would have fared just fine in the SEC last year...
Click to expand...

Texas pass defense was 125th last year and allowed 3561 yards (counting over 14 games). “https://cfbstats.com/2023/leader/national/team/defense/split01/category10/sort05.html"

There were only 8 teams in the country that have allowed more passing yards than Texas (and none in the SEC)
 
  • Like
Reactions: bamaclimber
some_al_fan said:
Texas pass defense was 125th last year and allowed 3561 yards. “https://cfbstats.com/2023/leader/national/team/defense/split01/category10/sort05.html"

There were only 8 teams in the country that has allowed more passing yards than Texas.
Click to expand...
We can pencil whip this as much as you like but for the sake of time I think we can both agree on...

SEC Defense > PAC 12 Defense

We should also be able to agree that Washington's offense last year was exceptional and would have been successful against most any opponent.
 
  • Like
  • Thank You
Reactions: BamaMoon, The Ols and some_al_fan
bamadwain said:
I believe if we get him and Carver from Mississippi State I believe we are done at wr, Williams is the alpha dog and we don't need someone coming in who wants to be the man, we need guys who will accept their roles and a fit for CKD offense
Click to expand...
Germie should be back for his senior year. He was looking good the last half of the season. Cole Adams should be mended up. And Jalen Hale may be back, hopefully at 100%. He looked real good last year. And four who will be sophomores. Two more will give us 9 WRs. Unless more portal out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bamadwain
cdub55 said:
We can pencil whip this as much as you like but for the sake of time I think we can both agree on...

SEC Defense > PAC 12 Defense

We should also be able to agree that Washington's offense last year was exceptional and would have been successful against most any opponent.
Click to expand...
A good/great offense will always be at an advantage no matter their conference affiliation.

Doesn't mean a defense can't slow them down, but I think modern college football is offensive oriented. I know we bemoaned P. Gol*ing, but in most of those years we had an offense that could simply score more points than our opponents.

That may not sound like "old school Bama football" but we will never revisit that era in the modern age of offensive football.

Let's let Deboer do his thing. We'll be explosive....probably starting next year!
 
  • Like
  • Roll Tide!
Reactions: NoNC4Tubs, bamadwain, CrimsonRuss and 1 other person
BamaMoon said:
A good/great offense will always be at an advantage no matter their conference affiliation.

Doesn't mean a defense can't slow them down, but I think modern college football is offensive oriented. I know we bemoaned P. Gol*ing, but in most of those years we had an offense that could simply score more points than our opponents.

That may not sound like "old school Bama football" but we will never revisit that era in the modern age of offensive football.

Let's let Deboer do his thing. We'll be explosive....probably starting next year!
Click to expand...
The old man said it himself a couple years ago...defense no longer wins championships.

I know that was hard for him to admit, but it is what it is.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Ols
davefrat said:
The old man said it himself a couple years ago...defense no longer wins championships.

I know that was hard for him to admit, but it is what it is.
Click to expand...

I know it kills him but he also knows it is because the rules have been changed to ensure defense doesn't win championships. I bet that eats at him in his sleep.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: The Ols and atlbama
Bamabuzzard said:
We haven't gotten much of anything in wrt to transfers. But we've had plenty go out. We need to start getting some in or we're going to be on the outside looking in. I really want the kid from Miami. 6'4 201 lb wr.
Click to expand...

That’s what I was seeing but hoped I missed something. Seems like WR, DB and DL are in a little trouble plus oline maybe. I know some young guys are here but proven guys and depth are lacking. I see some talk up the wrs we have and stuff but a lot is crimson glasses. I’ll trust staff for now but struggling this transfer market more than expected at the moment.
 
Coach D said:
That’s what I was seeing but hoped I missed something. Seems like WR, DB and DL are in a little trouble plus oline maybe. I know some young guys are here but proven guys and depth are lacking. I see some talk up the wrs we have and stuff but a lot is crimson glasses. I’ll trust staff for now but struggling this transfer market more than expected at the moment.
Click to expand...

I think a lot of kids jumped into the portal to see what they could get and if they didn't like it would portal back to their original team, if that option was available. In other words, there's a lot of window shopping going on right now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NoNC4Tubs
Bamabuzzard said:
We haven't gotten much of anything in wrt to transfers. But we've had plenty go out. We need to start getting some in or we're going to be on the outside looking in. I really want the kid from Miami. 6'4 201 lb wr.
Click to expand...
I think there was a post on another Alabama website that highlighted other SEC teams that have had a ton of outgoings, and not a ton incoming - UGA, OU, LSU were mentioned. It's not limited to Alabama, if that's what you're worried about. It's also trended that way since portal was originally opened, so the issue goes back to CNS' time. CNS' approach was to only target players in positions of need that could start immediately. CKD may be having the same strategy, but there are lots of backups leaving too, so he may also be targeting backups as well.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

New Posts

Advertisement

Trending content

Advertisement

Latest threads

Top Bottom
Back