For the critics of ICE, I have an honest question.
How would you characterize your position on immigration enforcement?
1) Do you want immigration laws enforced but not by ICE patrols inside the country? In other words, enforce immigration law at the border, but once inside the country, let them go?
2) What about visa overstays?
3) Do you want immigration laws enforced only insofar as illegal immigrants who commit violent or otherwise serious crimes are deported? (i.e. illegal immigrants who have simply worked, lived their lives, not broken any laws should stay?)
4) Do you not want immigration laws enforced at all?
5) Do you just not want ICE arresting Americans or shooting anyone, but otherwise are okay with ICE enforcing immigration law?
6) Some other position?
1) I want the current immigration laws enforced anywhere and everywhere there is a concern but especially at ports of entry into the country.
2) Our immigration system should be modernized similar to a passport system. Immigration, imo, ought to be like buying a cruise ticket. This should be easy and traceable. Pay a fee for the duration of your stay. Once it expires you have a limited time to self deport and deportation offices can be setup an international airports and you can apply for reentry there. People should not be afraid to engage with such a system. If you are avoiding the system we assume you have a criminal motive for doing so.
3) I would remove any illegal immigrants from our prisons as a first priority, they are taxing our system. Based on the severity of the crime, I would recommend immediate deportation on lesser crimes based on extradition treaty where the convict serves out his sentence in his home country. With more serious offenses, this approach may not be appropriate.
4) Yes, within the spirit of existing law. I think the majority of Americans want a well-administered immigration process.
5) Again, the 4A should govern how we pursue/detain illegal immigrants. I think a false arrest/imprisonment should result in pecuniary damages awarded to the detainee. A false arrest is highly defamatory and remediation should imposed by a court of law.
6) Again, this system is broken. I think the visa/passport can have varying levels of privileges based the compliance of your stay, working not working, etc. Voting privileges are accrued as a pathway to citizenship, not just because you are a seasonal worker, that should not take 10 years to achieve. All in all, employers should be encouraged to use the system with built-in safe harbors rather than avoid the system.