We use football analogies all the time to describe basketball, so how about a basketball analogy for football/quarterbacks:
There's no doubt this spring is about discovering the next Bama signal caller.
I try to remain open-minded about Jalen Milroe (trying to learn from my inability to see the possibilities with Jalen Hurts), BUT, to me Jalen Milroe is like a gifted athlete who has an awkward shooting motion in basketball. It just looks awkward coming out of his hand. In basketball terms, he might be the best athlete/fastest guy on the court, but B-ball is about getting the round ball in the round hoop. On the other hand, Ty Simpson looks to have a pure shooting motion; smooth and graceful without much effort - again, basketball analogy...
Can JM ever learn to throw with better motion (and most importantly better consistency/accuracy)? IMO, he just looks like a great athlete trying to play QB (granted, he's got a strong arm but seems to struggle with other throws).
BTW, the concern I had for Jalen Hurts was never in his throwing motion, just in his unwillingness to stand in the pocket and see the field.
So, I'd like to see JM improve and have a chance, but the eye test for me says TS will emerge as the eventual starter.