Link: Bama Has a QB Battle Between Sims and Ely

[RollTide1224]

Blake Simms I predict will start getting reps in pivotal times doing a "Wildcat Package" similar to what Ingram was used as 2 seasons ago. The only difference is that Simms is a very viable pass threat out of this set.

Understand this is pure speculation but I would be surprised if we didn't see it at some point soon.

If Lacy doesn't get going full strength I can see this being very possible.

 

[IMALOYAL1]

Rather than a QB battle, I think we are blessed with two capable QB's if we need them.

I like Blake Sims and have been impressed with his passing ability since A-Day two years ago. We already know he's a good runner. He may not be as tall as you'd like to run a pro style offense, but he seems to have an effective package built around his talents.

 

[bodiddle]

I hope the battle for 2nd spot between Sims and Ely is an illusion like the battle for the starting position between P. Sims & McCarron was an illusion in 2011. If the battle is for real, we really are in a world of hurt if for some reason McCarron can't go in the future.

Some of you posters have indicated that you don't understand what I am saying. The key is the word illusion. There was never any battle between P. Sims and McCarron. McCarron was always the starter. The fact that they both played in the Kent State game meant nothing.

Do you think that the coaching staff learned anything as a result of the Kent Game? They had both players on campus for several springs and falls, they already knew everything they needed to know about both players.

As to Sims and Ely, Sims will never be adequate as a complete fill-in or starter, so if Ely is that bad we are in bad trouble if McCarron can't go.

 

[RTR91]

Some of you posters have indicated that you don't understand what I am saying. The key is the word illusion. There was never any battle between P. Sims and McCarron. McCarron was always the starter. The fact that they both played in the Kent State game meant nothing.

Do you think that the coaching staff learned anything as a result of the Kent Game? They had both players on campus for several springs and falls, they already knew everything they needed to know about both players.

As to Sims and Ely, Sims will never be adequate as a complete fill-in or starter, so if Ely is that bad we are in bad trouble if McCarron can't go.

You don't think there was a QB battle? I hope you enjoy those presents Santa Claus (don't let anyone tell you he's not real) brings you in December.

 

[colbysullivan]

Some of you posters have indicated that you don't understand what I am saying. The key is the word illusion. There was never any battle between P. Sims and McCarron. McCarron was always the starter. The fact that they both played in the Kent State game meant nothing.

Do you think that the coaching staff learned anything as a result of the Kent Game? They had both players on campus for several springs and falls, they already knew everything they needed to know about both players.

As to Sims and Ely, Sims will never be adequate as a complete fill-in or starter, so if Ely is that bad we are in bad trouble if McCarron can't go.

sorry, but that's simply not true

 

[EscaTider]

Some of you posters have indicated that you don't understand what I am saying. The key is the word illusion. There was never any battle between P. Sims and McCarron. McCarron was always the starter. The fact that they both played in the Kent State game meant nothing.

Do you think that the coaching staff learned anything as a result of the Kent Game? They had both players on campus for several springs and falls, they already knew everything they needed to know about both players.

As to Sims and Ely, Sims will never be adequate as a complete fill-in or starter, so if Ely is that bad we are in bad trouble if McCarron can't go.

So in one spring and one series, you've seen everything that Sims can do as a QB? Seems a little premature to be speaking in absolutes.

 

[bodiddle]

So in one spring and one series, you've seen everything that Sims can do as a QB? Seems a little premature to be speaking in absolutes.[/QUOT

Apparently you didn't read what I said. Maybe you should read it before you comment.

 

[bodiddle]

You don't think there was a QB battle? I hope you enjoy those presents Santa Claus (don't let anyone tell you he's not real) brings you in December.

As soon as i get through opening the presents, I am going to sell you a bridge I own in Brooklyn.

How many games did Sims start in 2011?

 

[EscaTider]

So in one spring and one series, you've seen everything that Sims can do as a QB? Seems a little premature to be speaking in absolutes.[/QUOT

Apparently you didn't read what I said. Maybe you should read it before you comment.

Um...I read your post and responded with my thoughts. Everyone doesn't have to agree with you.

 

[RTR91]

As soon as i get through opening the presents, I am going to sell you a bridge I own in Brooklyn.

How many games did Sims start in 2011?

Since AJ started against Kent State, there was no battle? The two split time in that game and the following week until AJ solidified the spot.

 

[CullmanTide]

I hope the battle for 2nd spot between Sims and Ely is an illusion like the battle for the starting position between P. Sims & McCarron was an illusion in 2011. If the battle is for real, we really are in a world of hurt if for some reason McCarron can't go in the future.

Some of you posters have indicated that you don't understand what I am saying. The key is the word illusion. There was never any battle between P. Sims and McCarron. McCarron was always the starter. The fact that they both played in the Kent State game meant nothing.

Do you think that the coaching staff learned anything as a result of the Kent Game? They had both players on campus for several springs and falls, they already knew everything they needed to know about both players.

As to Sims and Ely, Sims will never be adequate as a complete fill-in or starter, so if Ely is that bad we are in bad trouble if McCarron can't go.

We understand what you're saying. Most here would disagree with you. There was little if any separation between the two until the Penn St. game when AJ showed his poise and leadership. They are very similar athletically and it seems to me Coach was trying to figure out which was going to become the leader of the team.

 

[IMALOYAL1]

There was never any battle between P. Sims and McCarron. McCarron was always the starter. The fact that they both played in the Kent State game meant nothing.

Do you think that the coaching staff learned anything as a result of the Kent Game? They had both players on campus for several springs and falls, they already knew everything they needed to know about both players.

As to Sims and Ely, Sims will never be adequate as a complete fill-in or starter, so if Ely is that bad we are in bad trouble if McCarron can't go.

I guess we will just disagree on both points. The 1st point is moot but on the 2nd, I think Blake Sims could be a serviceable QB. Heck if he was all we had I think with a few tweaks to our offense he could be a winning QB in the SEC. Your definition of 'adequate' may be different than mine.

I think we both agree AJ staying healthy greatly increases our chances to repeat for the BCS Championship this year.

 

[buzzincuzzin]

Arkansas game will help decide Alabama's 2/3 QB rotation for 2012.
That's a far cry from selling their fan-base on contending for the SEC West.

 

[Florida Tom]

Arkansas game will help decide Alabama's 2/3 QB rotation for 2012.
That's a far cry from selling their fan-base on contending for the SEC West.

Agree, I hoped we would see a lot of them both last week but it did not work out instead What CNS said about respecting your opponent came true.

I really think we may see both this Saturday, I hope so. Look at all the teams that had a lot tougher time than us last week and for those who forgot, AJ threw 4 TD the second week in a row. How long since that happened? We had 4 huge fumbles due to hard licks, when? Finally, the score was 35-0 & you would have thought we won a tight game.

 

[IMALOYAL1]

AJ threw 4 TD the second week in a row.

Did I miss a game or a TD pass or two?


ok. i think u meant he threw for a touchdown?

 

[buzzincuzzin]

Did I miss a game or a TD pass or two?


ok. i think u meant he threw for a touchdown?

A???? really???? A?????

Welcome to the future.. Please stay on the yellow line.

 

[TidefaninOS]

Some of you posters have indicated that you don't understand what I am saying. The key is the word illusion. There was never any battle between P. Sims and McCarron. McCarron was always the starter. The fact that they both played in the Kent State game meant nothing.

Do you think that the coaching staff learned anything as a result of the Kent Game? They had both players on campus for several springs and falls, they already knew everything they needed to know about both players.

As to Sims and Ely, Sims will never be adequate as a complete fill-in or starter, so if Ely is that bad we are in bad trouble if McCarron can't go.

Just wondering - do you have access to all of Bama's practices? Coach's meetings, etc?

Thanks in advance.

 

[CapstoneTider]

Just wondering - do you have access to all of Bama's practices? Coach's meetings, etc?

Thanks in advance.

While I usually agree with you, I too believe that A.J pretty much knew he was the starter during those first two games. I could tell after one series that one of the two was better. Around the same time there were whispers that Alabama will only play white qb'S, and coach Saban of course is not like this and was recruiting a blue chip in state black qb around that time. So from the two, I came to the conclusion that since one was obviously better, for recruiting purposes it was in the programs best interest to let everyone judge for themselves, and that plan worked out imo, as no was questioning the decision. If he had not allowed Sims to play, we would have been pegged as not giving Sims a chance, that he was really better(non contact a-day) and fans would have asking for him to play at every A.J mistake. But the quarterback "showing" clearly showed a Sims that looked bothered by large crowds. I believe he will overcome this, but I think he has a little stage fright. Which is common, I have it myself as a musician.

On my own opinion, it's good that a quarterback from Mobile is exceeding. Mobile is a favorite fishing hole for the coaches.

 

[TidefaninOS]

Oh, I think AJ knew he was the starter, too. I was just wondering if the poster was insinuating that P. Sims didn't get a fair chance in spring training & fall practice to earn the starting job. I hope that's not the case.

 

[CapstoneTider]

Oh, I think AJ knew he was the starter, too. I was just wondering if the poster was insinuating that P. Sims didn't get a fair chance in spring training & fall practice to earn the starting job. I hope that's not the case.

gotcha