Re: Saban's 06 class
As some mentioned earlier, it's really not even fair to call the 2007 class a "Saban" class.
He basically did as well as he could with what he had, and he actually added some very good players down the stretch. At the very least, we picked up Kareem Jackson, Josh Chapman, Darius Hanks, Luther Davis, Marquis Maze, and Jeramie Griffin, and I can assure you that we would not have gotten a single one of those players had Shula stuck around. For that, i.e. making the best of a bad situation, he deserves a lot of credit.
Again, though, on the whole it's just not that good of a class, period. Chris Lett and Jamar Taylor were gone before they really started, and Nick Fanuzzi and Tarence Farmer quickly transferred. Jeremy Elder was arrested and kicked off the team, and both Patrick Crump and Jennings Hester went on medical scholarship. Beyond that, many other members of the class look to face long odds right now in terms of making a meaningful impact in the next couple of years.
We'll get some good players out of this class, no doubt about it, but the quality depth just isn't there, and at the end of the day it will pale in comparison to the classes from 2008 and beyond.