<font face="Verdana, Arial" size="2">Originally posted by JohnD:
Doing your best to scare the commitments off?????? I mean information is good, but let's be smart about what you put on a free board.
</font>
Are you saying the players Alabama recruits can't read?
Are you saying the coaching staff isn't up front with every recruit?
Are you saying we hide the truth so maybe a recruit will commit and then ah ha! we got them?
Maybe you should go to another team if you can't answer these questions.
With that out of the way, YES, these number arer misleading.
First Carter, will he be ready to assume a starting role? No one knows till he gets out on the field. Coaches have said they will go easy with him in spring practice.
Brooks, he's like 5'5" or something, hardly the type of receiver Shula is now recruiting.
Givens, prototype size, but can't get routes down.
Roach could move to safety.
McKnight and McDowell are walk ons.
McDaniel might move to DB.
Jones is a walk on.
Knight may play OLB.
So now you are down to 6 WR's
Prothro
Caddell
Stover
Brown
Hall
Oakley
Stamps
Still look for at least 1 surprise out of the walk ons.
BTW, John D they are true freshmen. Does that help?