I don’t think anyone here has given up on Milroe. But there is work, a lot of it, that has to be done. But if Buchner has continued to improve to the point of passing JM in terms of understanding and executing the offense, then the only way to find out is give him a shot. And finding out against USF is probably better than finding out next week against Ole Miss.
I'm guessing someone hasn't gotten around to reading all the threads yet?