Cutcliff has earned the reputation of being a very good offensive mind. But, I see trouble this time around for his move back to UT.
First, Cutcliff has openly stated that he wants another head coaching job. He has tasted the top job with reasonable success (thanks to Eli) and I believe he will not be content until he is back in the saddle as a HC somewhere. (Ole Miss made a huge error in judgement when they fired him).
Second, how will Fulmer handle the possibility that a proven head coach on his staff could turn the tables on him and end up replacing him? This is a real possibility and Cutcliff could end up being a threat to Fulmer. Ut will not have consistent success until disclipline is restored. Cutcliff can not restore discipline by himself. That responsibility is squarely on the shoulders of Fulmer and he has not demonstrated any desire to clamp down on the troublemakers on and off the field. It is the lack of discipline that will continue to plague the team. Character counts.
Finally, the second time around is rarely as successful as the first. This applies to almost anything in life, especially in the business world. SEC football is nothing more than a big business. I have witnessed this on several occasions and, in most cases, it does not work out. For some reason, things are just not the same. I think Cutcliffs tenue at UT will be very short this time around (unless he unseats Fulmer).