I say a win one way or the other of 8-4.
Should win the 4 non-conference games, though Hawaii is a little scary.
Should beat both Mississippi schools, though Ole Miss plays a type of game we don't match up well against.
Should beat Vandy.
That leaves one win against Arkansas, Florida, Tennessee, LSU and Auburn.
Losing record -- Anything's possible in college football, but this would be a huge surprise.
6-6 -- not likely unless there's some sort of off-the-field implosion or a rash of key injuries.
7-5 -- That would imply (1) a loss in one of the "should win" games -- Ole Miss or Hawaii seem the best candidates to me, or (2) 0-5 against Arkansas, UF, UT, LSU and Auburn. Possible, but we'd have to have more bad luck than good (referee calls, breaks of the game, or injuries) for this to happen.
8-4 -- My personal most-likely case.
9-3 -- That means we win all seven of the "shoulds", beat Arkansas, and one of the UF/UT/LSU/Auburn murderer's row. Possible, but would require the breaks evening out in the key games, an OL improving to average in the SEC, and not many injuries. Florida strikes me as the best chance to pull this off.
10 -2 or better -- Shula gets national coach of the year, winning all the games in which we have equal or better material, and splitting the tough road games. The OL is a pleasant surprise, and we have no injuries that cause key players to miss time against the big 5.. Again: possible, but not likely.
So sez me. The next game I coach will be my first.