Also noteworthy although the comparisons may not be quite as relevant: through 6 games, DeBoer has the best record of any UA coach in his first season in the post-Bryant era:
Ray Perkins 1983: 4-2
Bill Curry 1987: 4-2
Gene Stallings 1990: 3-3
Mike Dubose 1997: 3-3
Dennis Franchione 2001: 3-3
Mike Shula 2003: 2-4
Nick Saban 2007: 4-2
Stallings in particular had some really bad losses in those first six games, and had taken over a team that was 10-2 and SEC co-champion the season before. Some perspective helps - give these guys some time to work things out.
Wallace Wade 1923: 4-1-1
Frank Thomas 1931: 5-1
Red Drew 1947: 4-2
JB Whitworth 1954: 0-6
Paul Bryant 1958: 3-2-1
As to who Alabama is I will append some info I posted elsewhere on the Board with a few additions.
Last year Alabama had 2 lockdown corners and 2 top edge rushers. Their absence without similar replacements, dramatically changes this D. The safeties were better also. Bama does not have overall elite talent on D or O, this, along with a change to a one-gap system with 2-gap personnel in the front 7 has greatly reduced Bama’s potential.
With far superior and more compatible personnel last year, Alabama lost 2 games and played 4 more one-score games, including a 6 pt win vs 6 loss A&M, 3 pt wins vs 7 loss AU and 8 loss Ark @ home. Only had 2 blowout (21+ pts) wins vs P5 teams.
They also had 5 one score games in both 21 & 22 as well as 5 in 23. Many (8) were vs 6+ loss teams in those years. Playing close, including vs mediocre to bad competition is not a recent phenomenon. This year may end up 10-2 to 8-4 which would be good to “understandable”, but dominance other than 2016 (no NC) & 2020 has been absent since a one loss 2012 which had its own hiccup.
The memory of the Alabama fan base is very selective. The program has been sliding on and off the field for a while. The dominance was real for 5 years then the game changed ~2012 but CNS did a great job adapting and recruiting improved but things simply were not the same after the focus changed to offense and officials often refused to call IMDF.
The 3 years prior to this had over one third, ~40%, of the games be within one score, several (8 to be precise) were vs teams with 6+ losses. With all of the massive changes (didn’t 41 players leave the program after last year, including not only the secondary starters but the depth also) that have taken place, 5-1 seems reasonable. That’s on top of the sport’s changes that all have experienced.
That’s not to say that improvement from the HC and staff is not needed but they a owed some patience and understanding and IMO, are being over criticized and compared to a record unknown in the history of the sport in reality and when remembered imprecisely it is a record that cannot be approached.
As CA has mentioned more than once, to cudgel this HC at this point is how you become AU. He has a stellar though admittedly sparse record at this level. He has a QB dependent system with a QB that does not fit, though he and Jalen have made meaningful improvement.