Why would Milroe or any other player think about transferring when he is getting the majority of the snaps with the 1’s. That tells me CNS had him at QB 1 all off season and that the real battle was for QB 2.
Bama Game Thread: Official Postgame Thread - Bama vs. UTw...
- Thread starter TIDE-HSV
- Start date
-
HELLO AGAIN, Guest! We are back, live! We're still doing some troubleshooting and maintenance to fix a few remaining issues but everything looks stable now (except front page which we're working on over next day or two) Thanks for your patience and support! MUCH appreciated! --Brett (BamaNation) if you see any problems - please post them in the Troubleshooting board!
Well everyone gave Daboll hell all season about not adjusting to Jalen’s talent. But at some point you realize breaking a quarterback from a one read and go tendency is like dealing with a dog who takes a love of chasing cars. You aren’t going to break his worst tendencies other than calling out who is going to throw to for him pre snap. It’s not something you can do during a season and is something you have to break in camp. I don’t think Rees will ever be able to run his offense with Milroe nor do I think he will able to force Saban to make the changes needed like Daboll did.
With respect, I think you’re being naive. Saban has encouraged many players to transfer over the years. He’s not the only one by any means, it’s a very common practice. Sometimes you just have to cut your losses when you completely whiff on player evaluation.
And let me add two things here: first, it may have been a moot point, if it indeed was a fumble, IF* the Alabama player closest to the sideline touched it while out of bounds. Second, why was NOBODY on the Alabama sideline in the side judge’s ear about a review? It is a crucial point in the game. You at the very least “lobby†to get it looked at.
But you are 100% correct. It should have at least been looked at. I’ve seen far more obvious reviewed.
This team, with Milroe at QB, on the road in an SEC game.......with no defense fearing his passing capabilities or just flat out baiting him into bad throws....well, things could get really ugly.
Either we run an option offense with Milroe and hope for the best or a change needs to be made. If Buchner and Simpson are no better then give Lonergan a shot and give him some experience for next year.
Either we run an option offense with Milroe and hope for the best or a change needs to be made. If Buchner and Simpson are no better then give Lonergan a shot and give him some experience for next year.
It’s too late to switch to an option offense. That decision should have been made in the spring. If we don’t change our QB, we will lose at least 3 more games.
Cruloc….here’s the really sad thing. With those to interceptions there was really no “baitingâ€Â. JM either predetermined his receiver or never read the coverage. I’m leaning towards “never seeing/reading†the coverage.
Interceptions happens…tips, batted balls, overthrows, etc.. But those two interceptions weren’t just bad. They were awful.
Milroe threw 2 picks directly to the other team. He had time to throw several times and bailed. One time he literally ran right into a sack after several seconds in the pocket. He is not a QB.
Daboll didnt know what to do with Jalen either...
There are bad fits between OC and QB and Rees and Milroe is one of them...
There are bad fits between OC and QB and Rees and Milroe is one of them...
That is all on Saban for continuing to play the wrong QB, in both cases.
He probably is lucky to be only at two picks. I counted 5 should be picks.
Well for starters they wouldn’t have to defend a 20-yard field.
If we hadn’t changed our philosophy, I’m certain we would have won NCs in 2018 and 2019.
His receivers bailed him out on numerous occasions last night. There were also a couple versus MTSU he telegraphed in the opener.
Could we be looking at a case of “look what Hurts was eventually able to do†and thinking that Milroe maybe has the same or better potential? I’m just spitballing. Don’t doubt Milroe doesn’t put in the work, it just hasn’t clicked yet. And with Hurts, I kinda feel like he had to get benched before he really committed to learn to be a passing QB who could read a defense and not use his athletic gifts to bail him out all the time.
We have what, 5 QB’s on scholarship? Simpson came in with a lot of fanfare and has a year under his belt. 2 of the 5, Milroe and Simpson, were supposed to have been developed over the last year as Bryce Young’s backup. Seems they weren’t. I remember BOB telling a reporter all the things Milroe couldn’t do which was relayed on the air in a game. I swear it feels like BOB didn’t bother to try and develop players like he knew he wasn’t going to be around to have to deal with it. Maybe I’m wrong but I swear the QB room ought to be farther along than this.
I need to add, what happened last night in no way was all on the QB. There was a myriad of things that went wrong
So Rees, as OC, now finds himself in the same position that Golding resided as DC the last few years. He doesn't have any control over his personnel or offensive strategy. Golding didn't have as DC. Daboll didn't have it with Jalen and only got it with the likelihood of losing the NC.
Staff management has been really poor by Saban for awhile. His gameplan box is too small. It took elite OCs in Kiffen and Sark to put a second leg on the dynasty or it would have ended in 2012.
Staff management has been really poor by Saban for awhile. His gameplan box is too small. It took elite OCs in Kiffen and Sark to put a second leg on the dynasty or it would have ended in 2012.
Trending content
Latest threads
-
-
-
-
ESPN: Sources: LSU officials discussing Kelly's future- Started by TideFans Reporter
- Replies: 0