Link: 2026 Transfer Portal

I just get the feeling that we are striking out in the portal based on two factors: 1) Not enough NIL $$ to compete, and 2) Recruits not believing in this staff. I hope I’m wrong about #2.
More the former and less the later. There are players that would love to come to Alabama. But they are the blue collar type that are playing at the lower levels. We need to find the right ones and that is a lot of work. Not sure we are set up for that yet.
 
again: Not sure how legit it is. I keep seeing this.


I will reiterate that people will try to make money an excuse, but Alabama didn't have to get in bidding wars for guys Texas was going after. They chose to. That's a strategic move.

Part of the issue to me is that this staff is either getting out-worked or over-whelmed. There's a period where they generally hit their stride, the team is playing good football, they are recruiting well then you get to that late season and suddenly things look a lot worse.

2024 it was the Oklahoma and Michigan losses, one of which knocked Alabama out of the playoff/SECCG and both of which were to teams with mediocre records. Followed up with a weak portal class that actually turned out worse than the already weak rankings.
2025 we saw the blowout losses to Georgia and Indiana, and a portal class that seems to be similarly flailing, with neither quantity nor quality.

I hope it isn't what it looks like, I want to see something better. I can say this much, it's not just money. Money is only an obstacle to people that try to spend their way out of every problem. Money is only an issue in this case because Alabama went head to head with Texas. They also lost out on a guy to South Carolina they wanted while chasing guys Texas wanted. Believe me, South Carolina isn't richer than Alabama in any way, shape or form.
I will post a link to something I saw today. Please look at who’s ranked 1st. They’re involved with the NCAA championship game and do not employ a “GM.”

I know where we could save $1,000,000. This is RIDICULOUS.
 
  • Smash Keyboard
Reactions: The Ols
I will post a link to something I saw today. Please look at who’s ranked 1st. They’re involved with the NCAA championship game and do not employ a “GM.”

I know where we could save $1,000,000. This is RIDICULOUS.

Actually they do… they just go by its traditional name. Saban even had one. DeBoer just calls it a GM but it’s basically a recruiting director

IU
 
BTW, we are not the only team struggling in the portal. I think most are. Thing we got going for us is a top 5 recruiting class coming in focused on making us better.
THIS! We are always going to be a program who primarily builds through high school recruiting, and it also happens to be the more sustainable model We are better equipped to handle portal struggles than most of the other teams, because we consistently nail high school recruiting. And I know people worry about being able to keep them, but I'm pretty we sure we still have every player we want from DeBoer's first class, so it's clear those guys have bought in.
 
We basically have the college football equivalent of dodgers or yankees. they can just throw all the money at every high profile player. Everyone else just gets the scraps because they will never be able to compete with the teams with all the money.

Edit: By "we" I mean college football fans.
This is what MLB looked like roughly 100 years ago... 🙄
 
Frustrating That we are wasting time on skill positions that we cannot afford and do not really need when we do not even have first string OL to put on the field.

We do need some depth at WR.

The main portion of the money, I hope, is going to OL and DL though.
 
Alabama is currently the favorite in many Offensive linemen, and is still targeting a few receivers. I never saw Coleman as a true possibility but was convinced it was possible a few days ago.

I think we arent going to get a “splash” unless Noah Rogers signs…. But hasn’t this been what everyone has been asking for?
I was involved with baseball while at the University of North Alabama. Coach Lane had multiple contact and great relationships with MLB scouts. Granted, this was pre travel ball, showcase, etc. A good source for info concerning these diamonds in the rough would be through NFL scouts. They are looking at players across all levels and know a great deal concerning who at whatever school you’ve scouted could help us at X position.
 
For the record according to 247, Alabama has the 49th ranked portal class, this after losing 20 guys via the portal. They started out with staff chirping about how they weren't losing anything of importance.

Clearly this is just about money though, since college football heavyweights like Kentucky and Arizona St. have top 10 portal classes. To put it in another context, Alabama now has the second worst portal class in the conference.

And mind you, if they were racking up on sleepers I'd be alright with it and say let's wait to see how these guys pan out. But it's still as of this moment a single digit class, even counting the walk-on tight end!
Yep, but rankings are based on stars. Stars are based on services who rate players in high school. Frankly, that is a very flawed system so you really have to do your own evals to know what you are getting. Another point is character. Many of these star players are not as coachable as the kid working his butt off wanting to play a role on a team.
 
  • Like
Reactions: crimsonkelly
I will reiterate that people will try to make money an excuse, but Alabama didn't have to get in bidding wars for guys Texas was going after. They chose to. That's a strategic move.

Part of the issue to me is that this staff is either getting out-worked or over-whelmed. There's a period where they generally hit their stride, the team is playing good football, they are recruiting well then you get to that late season and suddenly things look a lot worse.

2024 it was the Oklahoma and Michigan losses, one of which knocked Alabama out of the playoff/SECCG and both of which were to teams with mediocre records. Followed up with a weak portal class that actually turned out worse than the already weak rankings.
2025 we saw the blowout losses to Georgia and Indiana, and a portal class that seems to be similarly flailing, with neither quantity nor quality.

I hope it isn't what it looks like, I want to see something better. I can say this much, it's not just money. Money is only an obstacle to people that try to spend their way out of every problem. Money is only an issue in this case because Alabama went head to head with Texas. They also lost out on a guy to South Carolina they wanted while chasing guys Texas wanted. Believe me, South Carolina isn't richer than Alabama in any way, shape or form.
So if you were CKD or GM CM, what would you do?

Being a critic is the easiest job in the world, so I am anxious to hear your plan...:unsure:
 
THIS! We are always going to be a program who primarily builds through high school recruiting, and it also happens to be the more sustainable model We are better equipped to handle portal struggles than most of the other teams, because we consistently nail high school recruiting. And I know people worry about being able to keep them, but I'm pretty we sure we still have every player we want from DeBoer's first class, so it's clear those guys have bought in.
Yep, and Alabama is a brand. Arguably, we have the best brand on the planet. We don't have a lot of billionaires but we do have a great history and, really, the best group of fans on the planet. We will be alright but there will be a rocky road ahead.
 
Alabama is currently the favorite in many Offensive linemen, and is still targeting a few receivers. I never saw Coleman as a true possibility but was convinced it was possible a few days ago.

I think we arent going to get a “splash” unless Noah Rogers signs…. But hasn’t this been what everyone has been asking for?
Nice post. I'd argue that a cannon ball splash is less impressive in a diving competition. Let's dig deep and get some blue collar guys that can open some holes in the running game.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Transplanted
Yep, but rankings are based on stars. Stars are based on services who rate players in high school. Frankly, that is a very flawed system so you really have to do your own evals to know what you are getting. Another point is character. Many of these star players are not as coachable as the kid working his butt off wanting to play a role on a team.
I'd agree with you except this is clearly a lack of quantity or quality.

For instance, Kentucky is listed as 17 portal additions and Alabama is listed as 5 via 247. Now this doesn't include unranked/walk-on players. For Alabama that's a punter, longer snapper, and tight end.

But that's the whole class! This isn't a stars ranking situation, it's just a... there's nothing there situation. They are tied for the smallest portal class in the SEC as well!

So if you were CKD or GM CM, what would you do?

Being a critic is the easiest job in the world, so I am anxious to hear your plan:unsure:
I've actually said it a few times. But first let's considering the GM's role. He's being paid a million dollars JUST to manage the roster. A lot of teams don't even have that role, so he basically should spend a ton of his time evaluating talent. There should be a big board with hundreds, even thousands of names, people he's evaluated, needs to evaluate, what their evaluations are, who needs additional looks, etc..

And a big part of that should be the sleeper list. That's the list of cheap guys that Alabama can get basically at no cost to the NIL budget. They are freebies, or close to freebies. You find them, your offer basically instantly outbids any interested party. There are thousands of players in the portal, you want to find the ones that were overlooked.

Those are the very first guys you sign once the portal opens! Alabama has 30 slots available! They don't have to fill them all, but if it's not a numbers issue and it's not an NIL issue, why not round up a half dozen of these guys the instant the portal opens? They'll be excited a major program is offering them, and you'll be landing your sleeper picks from the start. The lack of total signings is the red flag to me, it means they're not doing much of these deep dives. In fact of the 3 sleeper type picks in place right now, two play football in the state and a third had an old social media post saying he wanted to play for Alabama. So I'm not even sure if they contacted Alabama or Alabama contacted them.

Then there's the big money stuff. That will be hard, but basically if your evaluation is better than the other guys, you won't be getting in as many fights over the top recruiting ranking service players. You also sidestep programs like Texas, you only bid to bid them up, but you don't roll out the red carpet and all that on bidding wars with Texas! No one they are bidding for will come cheap! So what do you do? You beat out South Carolina, you beat out those sort of programs, instead Alabama lost to programs like South Carolina as well while being distracted by Texas!
 
Last edited:

New Posts

Advertisement

Advertisement

Latest threads