Jimmy Johns, good all around, but outstanding at which position?

TIDE-HSV said:
I gave the reason that Sparky thinks he's special. And he should know talent. However, I agree with the rest of posters that the title is awful. "Overrated" is usually the modifier used just above "bust" on the expectation thermometer. I'm going to change it to something a little less charged...

I agree with the "jack of all trades" point made by Vertical, but the thread title was merely downplaying the talk that JJ (like I said before) is the next coming of Shaun Alexander. Everybody seems to think he can just jump in and be a superstar. The pervading feelings and expectations are much higher than where I believe they should be set.

The thread title, while a little coarse, is not predicting the end of the world, and has been blown out of proportion.

I'll start the deep-breathing exercises... hopefully some others will follow. ;)
 
Last edited:
As has been mentioned, and discussed, numerous times on this board, there's more to being a RB in CMS's system, than just running with the ball. Reading, and picking up, blitzes, blocking, catching passes out of the backfield are just a few, but JJ even goes them one better......he can also throw a pass effectively! I don't believe I'd sell him short just yet. Remember, he's just one year out of High School!
 
As we staff...

say, over and over again (while deep-breathing), it's frequently not what you say so much as it's the way you say it. If JJ turned to this page, he'd see "overrated" as a slap in the face. I would. If another recruit (or an opposing recruiter) turned to this page and saw that title, the first would say "Gee, and he was the MS Mister Football." The other would say "Man, I gotta bookmark this...."
 
One thing I think people need to realize about JJ playing RB is he wasnt a pure RB in high school. He stepped into that position with virtually ZERO experience. He didnt get to teach himself the small things RB's learn through experience. He can find a hole, I'll give him that... but lets give him some time to learn how to run slower to set up blocks, and run faster to set up defensive opponents to play themselves out of position. Most of the time a RB makes people miss while they are still 10 yards away.


I kind of relate him to Dennis Riddle, except with a ton of more talent. I remember when Riddle was young, and raw. He would take the pitch while running one of Stalling's signature sweeps and just run straight out of bounds. Everyone would be screaming to cut it up field, but at that time he hadn't learned to see those seams early enough to react to them. Then, suddenly, against LSU... it clicked for him. I was at that game and it was one of the biggest smiles I've had at a game (cept the FL Game this year heheh). A few years later he's catching a swing pass against Auburn to whip em.

Running deceptively, picking up cutback lanes, using your eyes presnap to make defenses 'pick a side', and seeing seams before they are really there are all things that JJ will probably learn as he progresses through this transition.

As of now, he is an excellent north-south runner that hits the hole hard and is EXTREMELY hard to tackle. I'll take that for a young, raw RB that has everthing to learn still.
 
Advertisement

Trending content

Advertisement

Latest threads