How quickly people forget. Both Kiffin and Sark were disliked as OC hires by a pretty large chunk of our fanbase. In fact, there were many complaining about Kiffin the entire time he was here.
Only when we look back on yon halcyon days do we forget how 'meh' many people felt about both Kiffin and Sark. I feel like I posted a thousand times about how we need to give them time, see what they can do. etc. And it wasn't just off the field stuff - I was digging up tons of stats showing what Kiffin andSark had each done while at USC, for example, but people argued they were a bad choice.
So no, neither one of them were considered 'home run hire' by anything remotely resembling a majority of the Bama fans here.