If you honestly think WVU is in the same category as Wake Forest, South Florida and Rutgers... well, I'm not sure you ought to be posting on any football forum. WVU, as you noted, beat the SEC champ 2 years ago and this year went 10-2 and beat the crap out of an MSU team Bama hasn't been able to beat in two years while WVU has beaten them by big margins both times.
Wake is 96th in all time wins, Rutgers is 38th (because they've played the most games in NCAA history) and South Florida hasn't gotten 50 wins yet.
Wake is 105th in winning percentage, Rugters is 78th and South Florida has only been around this century.
So you can't put them in the same category as WVU, you just can't.