Question: What are your thoughts on "tipping" waiters/waitresses?

BAMAFAN IN NY

Hall of Fame
Jan 2, 2007
5,697
22
62
49
Watertown, NY
www.myspace.com
You're proving my point for me. This is why those restaurants should pay their employees more. They're more valuable to those restaurants.
They are held to those standards by the CUSTOMERS. You expect the service to be on par with the amount of money youre spending.

I always think of it as my food costs X amount of dollars, plus a base of 20% for the service. I increase or decrease that amount based on my expectations of the level of service I should be getting.
 

CrimsonNagus

Hall of Fame
Jun 6, 2007
9,698
8,609
212
46
Montgomery, Alabama, United States
The price of the food is reduced because we tip!? Please, do some of you actually believe that crap? Is that why a burger at Applebee’s is at the bargain price of $9 without a drink? The price of the food at every restaurant is already significantly marked up; they are not giving anyone a deal on a meal because we tip. No, what the owners are doing is making more profit for themselves because we are supplementing their employee's salaries.

I tip my 15% but no more unless it is just amazing service. If you are a jerk of a server, then you get nothing from me. Sorry but you have to earn your tip from me; I do not feel obligated to give you anything at all. That's my problem with the whole thing; too many servers expect a tip before they have even earned it these days.

Please, can we stop it with the “small amount of money” that servers make talk? At the end of the day they will get at least minimum wage. No, that is not a lot of money but, you can survive on that. I've worked plenty of minimum wage jobs (didn't get tips either) and I'm still here.
 
Last edited:

Airborne Tider

All-American
Aug 2, 2008
3,369
0
0
Fort Benning
I just want to make two quick points:

1. TIPS doesn't come from any acronym meaning "to insure prompt service" that is an urban legend. Here is a link about the legend.

2. I stick to what many here have said, if you can't afford to tip at least 20% of your bill at the restaurant then you would be better off not eating there IMO.

I served and bartended and I have been stiffed before as well and yes it sucks to actually pay to wait on a table. I didn't realize so many people were against the entire practice of tipping until I ran across the thread. I am really amazed by that. Not saying anything bad about anyone, doesn't make you a bad person, just a bad table to wait on. I just never realized that some people had such a hardline stance on tipping. I assumed people were either just jerks or they didn't know any better. Now I know. At least the Army always pays me. :p
 

Bamabuzzard

FB Moderator
Staff member
Aug 15, 2004
33,183
27,864
337
49
Where ever there's BBQ, Bourbon & Football
The price of the food is reduced because we tip!? Please, do some of you actually believe that crap? Is that why a burger at Applebee’s is at the bargain price of $9 without a drink? The price of the food at every restaurant is already significantly marked up; they are not giving anyone a deal on a meal because we tip. No, what the owners are doing is making more profit for themselves because we are supplementing their employee's salaries.

I tip my 15% but no more unless it is just amazing service. If you are a jerk of a server, then you get nothing from me. Sorry but you have to earn your tip from me; I do not feel obligated to give you anything at all. That's my problem with the whole thing; too many servers expect a tip before they have even earned it these days.

Please, can we stop it with the “small amount of money” that servers make talk? At the end of the day they will get at least minimum wage. No, that is not a lot of money but, you can survive on that. I've worked plenty of minimum wage jobs (didn't get tips either) and I'm still here
.
I think what he meant was that if it was structured where the restaurant owners simply paid them a traditional hourly rate the current prices we do pay would be higher. I don't think it was meant that they actually "reduce" the price of the food. We all know that's not true.
 
I

It's On A Slab

Guest
As as aside. I've noticed that the wait staff at some of these really high-end places tend to be arrogant/snotty/aloof. As if they've waited on so many millionaires (who probably tip handily).

My wife asked for the house pinot at one of these restaurants, and the waiter huffed, "Ma'am, we don't have a house pinot."

She knew what was my knee-jerk response ("Well, eff you then.") so she shot me that "Don't do it!" look. :p
 

Bamabuzzard

FB Moderator
Staff member
Aug 15, 2004
33,183
27,864
337
49
Where ever there's BBQ, Bourbon & Football
I just want to make two quick points:

1. TIPS doesn't come from any acronym meaning "to insure prompt service" that is an urban legend. Here is a link about the legend.

2. I stick to what many here have said, if you can't afford to tip at least 20% of your bill at the restaurant then you would be better off not eating there IMO.

I served and bartended and I have been stiffed before as well and yes it sucks to actually pay to wait on a table. I didn't realize so many people were against the entire practice of tipping until I ran across the thread. I am really amazed by that. Not saying anything bad about anyone, doesn't make you a bad person, just a bad table to wait on. I just never realized that some people had such a hardline stance on tipping
. I assumed people were either just jerks or they didn't know any better. Now I know. At least the Army always pays me. :p

Why should what I pay you/waiter (in a tip) be based off an amount that has nothing to do with you? If my bill is $200 or $20, that figure that prints out on my ticket had absolutely nothing to do with the service or lack of service you provided during my time there. Whether I received mediocre service, great service or not so great service I'm still in debt of the stated ticket amount of $200 or $20. That price had everything to do with the food I ordered from the menu and the markup associated with it. Not a waiter making sure my drinks are refilled in a timely manner or they checked back every 2-3 minutes. It's not like if I didn't like the service I could reduce the ticket by 15%-20%. I still have to pay the ticket price.

I tip and rarely do I not. But I do not go by the ticket amount. I go by what I think the value the server brought to my dining experience based off what they actually did or didn't do. Don't see much wrong with that or how that is "being a jerk". I just don't associate ticket price with the amount I "should" tip.
 
Last edited:

Bamabuzzard

FB Moderator
Staff member
Aug 15, 2004
33,183
27,864
337
49
Where ever there's BBQ, Bourbon & Football
As as aside. I've noticed that the wait staff at some of these really high-end places tend to be arrogant/snotty/aloof. As if they've waited on so many millionaires (who probably tip handily).
My wife asked for the house pinot at one of these restaurants, and the waiter huffed, "Ma'am, we don't have a house pinot."

She knew what was my knee-jerk response ("Well, eff you then.") so she shot me that "Don't do it!" look. :p
You would think since wait staffs at higher end restaurants get less traffic than lower end they'd be less arrogant and a lot more friendly. But I'm sure they've gotten used to people basing their tip amount from ticket total. Do the same quality of work but get higher tips due to higher ticket prices. Imagine that. ;) :biggrin2:
 

RedStar

Hall of Fame
Jan 28, 2005
9,623
0
0
41
The Shoals, AL
Why should what I pay you/waiter (in a tip) be based off an amount that has nothing to do with you? If my bill is $200 or $20, that figure that prints out on my ticket had absolutely nothing to do with the service or lack of service you provided during my time there. Whether I received mediocre service, great service or not so great service I'm still in debt of the stated ticket amount of $200 or $20. That price had everything to do with the food I ordered from the menu and the markup associated with it. Not a waiter making sure my drinks are refilled in a timely manner or they checked back every 2-3 minutes. It's not like if I didn't like the service I could reduce the ticket by 15%-20%. I still have to pay the ticket price.

I tip and rarely do I not. But I do not go by the ticket amount. I go by what I think the value the server brought to my dining experience based off what they actually did or didn't do. Don't see much wrong with that or how that is "being a jerk". I just don't associate ticket price with the amount I "should" tip.
This paragraph nails it. It's what I've been trying to say, but obviously couldn't. +1 indeed.
 

ValuJet

Moderator
Sep 28, 2000
22,620
19
0
As as aside. I've noticed that the wait staff at some of these really high-end places tend to be arrogant/snotty/aloof. As if they've waited on so many millionaires (who probably tip handily).

My wife asked for the house pinot at one of these restaurants, and the waiter huffed, "Ma'am, we don't have a house pinot."

She knew what was my knee-jerk response ("Well, eff you then.") so she shot me that "Don't do it!" look. :p
I woulda started referring to him as "boy" and started snapping my fingers in the air when I wanted something - like Paulie did on The Sopranos.

"Ma'am we don't have a House Pinot" could have been replaced by a "Perfect. We have a Napa Pinot that is an excellent compliment to all our menu selections."

Hell, 99% of wine drinkers - me included - have no idea what we're buying, and like it would matter any way!. If the label is cool looking, that's half the decision. I know this on good authority.

Your waiter - did he stand there with his hands on his hips, the fingers facing toward the back? (No offense, Charmin). Some of those guys can be a little snotty sometimes. :)
 

CrimsonNagus

Hall of Fame
Jun 6, 2007
9,698
8,609
212
46
Montgomery, Alabama, United States
Also, tip inflation is out of control. Used to be 10%, then 15, and now people act like anything less than 20% is an insult.
Agreed. I tip the customary 15%, sometimes more for exceptional service. Don't tell me I shouldn't eat out because I'm not doing 20%. This goes back to my statement that too many servers think they have earned a tip before they've done anything to earn it. If you want 20%, you better go above and beyond the typical service, more then just showing up.
 

exiledNms

Hall of Fame
Aug 2, 2002
5,443
7
0
Hattiesburg, MS (USA)
I'm disappointed nobody has gone for the cheap, juvenile analogy to cow-tipping in this thread.

I would, but (a) I'm loaded up on Tex-Mex & thus about to fall asleep, and (b) the thread turned serious in a hurry. So I'll just toss out the cow-tipping phrase & let your minds wander around it aimlessly. ;)

exiled
 

Tide1986

Suspended
Nov 22, 2008
15,667
2
0
Birmingham, AL
Why should what I pay you/waiter (in a tip) be based off an amount that has nothing to do with you? If my bill is $200 or $20, that figure that prints out on my ticket had absolutely nothing to do with the service or lack of service you provided during my time there. Whether I received mediocre service, great service or not so great service I'm still in debt of the stated ticket amount of $200 or $20. That price had everything to do with the food I ordered from the menu and the markup associated with it. Not a waiter making sure my drinks are refilled in a timely manner or they checked back every 2-3 minutes. It's not like if I didn't like the service I could reduce the ticket by 15%-20%. I still have to pay the ticket price.

I tip and rarely do I not. But I do not go by the ticket amount. I go by what I think the value the server brought to my dining experience based off what they actually did or didn't do. Don't see much wrong with that or how that is "being a jerk". I just don't associate ticket price with the amount I "should" tip.
I totally get your perspective and even agree with it to some degree. However, I actually get more liberal with my tipping as restaurants move up the high-endedness scale. I'm already spending a good bit of money, so as long as the service is exceptional, I'll tend to tip much more than 20%. The menus at such restaurants tend to be far more complicated than those at Applebee's and Chili's and more complicated to explain and offer up recommendations as a result. Plus, it seems far more common these days for the servers at high-end restaurants to also serve as sommeliers of sorts. I personally think that the value of the service at a high-end restaurant is far greater than the service at an Applebee's or Chili's -- the service is much less transactional and much more consultative in my opinion.

Anyway, I'm not criticizing your perspective...I definitely understand and can relate to some degree with how you feel.
 
Last edited:

ValuJet

Moderator
Sep 28, 2000
22,620
19
0
I stated before that my family's legacy on dining out is to stiff the wait staff. Stiff the Staff, if you will.

My grandfather on my Mom's side was also a legendary cheapskate. During the Great Depression, there must have been NO tipping at all, and that carried over for the next 70 years, I suppose.

My oldest daughter was a hostess and server at a restaurant called Up The Creek - first job she had. When my grandparents snuffed out this information, they began going there after church every Sunday - to see their great granddaughter, but knowing them, thinking they would get a discount in addition oto the Senior Discount.

After a few weeks, everybody in the restaurant knew who they were. My grandparents would pay the bill in cash. If it was $19.85, they'd pay with a $20 and leave the $0.15 as a tip. It got to where my daughter was embarrassed - when they came in, whoever was assigned to their table, they'd go up to my daughter and say "I know it's your grandparents, but I don't want to wait on them."

To the restaurant folks here, do you notice people in their 80's and 90's are a little more frugal with their tipping generosity? :)
 

TIDE-HSV

Senior Administrator
Staff member
Oct 13, 1999
86,393
44,356
437
Huntsville, AL,USA
I stated before that my family's legacy on dining out is to stiff the wait staff. Stiff the Staff, if you will.

My grandfather on my Mom's side was also a legendary cheapskate. During the Great Depression, there must have been NO tipping at all, and that carried over for the next 70 years, I suppose.

My oldest daughter was a hostess and server at a restaurant called Up The Creek - first job she had. When my grandparents snuffed out this information, they began going there after church every Sunday - to see their great granddaughter, but knowing them, thinking they would get a discount in addition oto the Senior Discount.

After a few weeks, everybody in the restaurant knew who they were. My grandparents would pay the bill in cash. If it was $19.85, they'd pay with a $20 and leave the $0.15 as a tip. It got to where my daughter was embarrassed - when they came in, whoever was assigned to their table, they'd go up to my daughter and say "I know it's your grandparents, but I don't want to wait on them."

To the restaurant folks here, do you notice people in their 80's and 90's are a little more frugal with their tipping generosity? :)
Very interesting. For a brief interval, my daughter was an hostess at Olive Garden (thank god she moved on to becoming a successful international lawyer). I went in with a friend to eat lunch and left a cash tip. Not knowing the relationship, our server complained to her that I'd stiffed her. Knowing better, Rachel responded that I was her dad and she knew I never stiffed anyone. They did a sting operation and caught the busser stealing tips. The lesson is that the wait staff doesn't always know what you're leaving...
 

BSBHVR2

3rd Team
May 13, 2011
277
0
0
Alabama
Sorry, thought this had something to do with cows.

But tip your waiters and whatnot as they should be.
 
Last edited:

Airborne Tider

All-American
Aug 2, 2008
3,369
0
0
Fort Benning
This seems to be one of those topics you're never gonna change some ones opinion about. I know bad service when I see it. But I also know that there is A LOT that servers have to do besides just wait on tables. Every server would be thrilled if all they had to do was make sure your drink was full but they can't. They have "side work" that has to be accomplished as well. I know when a server is just busy and when they are just bad and it seems most people don't. As far as the "inflation" of tip percentages, that's because servers have to pay out more to the help(hostesses, bartended, etc.). If anyone has ever been to Europe then you can probably really appreciate the effort and attentiveness of most American servers. I don't make a lot of money, therefore I don't eat at high end restaurants very often. When I do eat out I usually leave at least 20-25% if the server does his job, bring me my stuff. So yeah if my tab is 50 bucks I will give a 10 dollar tip instead of 5-8 like some people, I'm not rich but 3-5 dollars that I would probably blow anyway seems like a small fee for the service. JMHO.

Sent from my Droid using Tapatalk
 

Bama Reb

Suspended
Nov 2, 2005
14,445
0
0
On the lake and in the woods, AL
Very interesting. For a brief interval, my daughter was an hostess at Olive Garden (thank god she moved on to becoming a successful international lawyer). I went in with a friend to eat lunch and left a cash tip. Not knowing the relationship, our server complained to her that I'd stiffed her. Knowing better, Rachel responded that I was her dad and she knew I never stiffed anyone. They did a sting operation and caught the busser stealing tips. The lesson is that the wait staff doesn't always know what you're leaving...
Which is why I try to make sure to hand the waiter/waitress my tip directly. I hate it when I leave a tip and the busboy (or another customer) picks up my tip. :mad:

Bamabuzzard said:
Why should what I pay you/waiter (in a tip) be based off an amount that has nothing to do with you? If my bill is $200 or $20, that figure that prints out on my ticket had absolutely nothing to do with the service or lack of service you provided during my time there. Whether I received mediocre service, great service or not so great service I'm still in debt of the stated ticket amount of $200 or $20. That price had everything to do with the food I ordered from the menu and the markup associated with it. Not a waiter making sure my drinks are refilled in a timely manner or they checked back every 2-3 minutes. It's not like if I didn't like the service I could reduce the ticket by 15%-20%. I still have to pay the ticket price.

I tip and rarely do I not. But I do not go by the ticket amount. I go by what I think the value the server brought to my dining experience based off what they actually did or didn't do. Don't see much wrong with that or how that is "being a jerk". I just don't associate ticket price with the amount I "should" tip.
^^^ +1^^^ Amen. .
 

Bamabuzzard

FB Moderator
Staff member
Aug 15, 2004
33,183
27,864
337
49
Where ever there's BBQ, Bourbon & Football
This seems to be one of those topics you're never gonna change some ones opinion about. I know bad service when I see it. But I also know that there is A LOT that servers have to do besides just wait on tables. Every server would be thrilled if all they had to do was make sure your drink was full but they can't. They have "side work" that has to be accomplished as well. I know when a server is just busy and when they are just bad and it seems most people don't. As far as the "inflation" of tip percentages, that's because servers have to pay out more to the help(hostesses, bartended, etc.). If anyone has ever been to Europe then you can probably really appreciate the effort and attentiveness of most American servers. I don't make a lot of money, therefore I don't eat at high end restaurants very often. When I do eat out I usually leave at least 20-25% if the server does his job, bring me my stuff. So yeah if my tab is 50 bucks I will give a 10 dollar tip instead of 5-8 like some people, I'm not rich but 3-5 dollars that I would probably blow anyway seems like a small fee for the service. JMHO.

Sent from my Droid using Tapatalk
It seems you tip in the same range that I do. Though I do not go by the ticket amount my tips range from $3-$10 with $10 being about as high as I'll go.
 
I

It's On A Slab

Guest
It seems you tip in the same range that I do. Though I do not go by the ticket amount my tips range from $3-$10 with $10 being about as high as I'll go.
We always hit happy hour at local pubs on Friday. Half-price drinks and appetizers. I tip really well on those outings. Drinks and pub food rarely totals more than $20. I'd be a total arse if I didn't tip well. At those places, the bartenders and servers are busting it to keep folks supplied with food and beverages.
 

Bamabuzzard

FB Moderator
Staff member
Aug 15, 2004
33,183
27,864
337
49
Where ever there's BBQ, Bourbon & Football
We always hit happy hour at local pubs on Friday. Half-price drinks and appetizers. I tip really well on those outings. Drinks and pub food rarely totals more than $20. I'd be a total arse if I didn't tip well. At those places, the bartenders and servers are busting it to keep folks supplied with food and beverages.
I'll agree here. One of my wife and mine's favorite restaurant is setup a lot like a pub. You can sit in the bar area and order from menu, drink, watch tv and shoot the bull with the bartenders. Those guys in that area bust there humps and hustle it constantly. I normally drop some extra coin on them as well.
 

New Posts

Latest threads