Vandy was very good through the 20s, they were decent thereafter til '59. They were never close to being 1 or 2 in the SEC from its inception in '33 thru '59. Bama, LSU, UT, UGA, GT, Tulane, OM were better programs during that period, all of whom won 3 or more SEC titles. In fact, 9 programs had won titles by then. Vandy never won one, they only had 9 winning SEC records in the 27 seasons from '33-'59, only one of which was more than 2 games over .500. AU was just not very good from '22-'52 - 9 winning seasons. The first 20 years of the SEC, '33-52, AU had 5 winning SEC seasons and 5 winless seasons. Though in the bottom half of the SEC, Vandy was just better than AU. Then in Shug's 3rd season in '53 things dramatically turned around, then Coach Bryant arrived in '58. AU remained decent to good, but not at the sustained level they had from '53-60, .793. From '61 to the end of Bryant's tenure .621.They had our number before 1960. Not too shocking, as they were 1 of the 2 best programs in the SEC until right around the time Bear came along, then they had a major drop off from which they never recovered.
2 of the last 3 times they played us they caught us having very poor seasons, 2008 before Tommy's firing and 2012 before Gene's.