I don't necessarily disagree, but look at South Carolina losing to 9-3 Illinois, who no one suggested deserved a playoff berth.They still didn't deserve to be in, but they could have put in South Carolina or Ole Miss.
Ole Miss? They will probably lose too because Kiffin. But I think today proves that Alabama was really the team that went 5-4 after the Georgia game, not the one that had gone 4-0 through the Georgia game.

