I agree with ya Brother..You can make an argument for either or I think you could anyways..
Guy was a tad bit before my time, I grew up idolizing Roby, I'd get made fun of playing backyard football, I always chose to be Reggie Roby when we picked players..He may have been a punter, but, I always thought he walked in water..
I think Roby was the best ever when it came to consistently punting the ball long with hangtime..
He also had the best ball control placing where exactly he wanted the ball to go I've seen a punter have..