I'm not, but I'm also not questioning if CKD's new style works.
Obviously, it works. Look at Washington before he got there and compare it to last year.
I will also say that I think Coach has done a great job of balancing keeping some things the same (he referred to the 4th quarter program yesterday in his PC) but also knowing where some change was needed.
I don't think he's a Ray Perkins.
DeBoer is definitely not Ray Perkins redux. About six months into Perkins' tenure, the common joke was that if Ray Perkins hadn't hacked you off, it was only because you hadn't yet met him.
I haven't heard a whisper of that with DeBoer.
In front of a crowd, DeBoer seems to be personable but not overly so. He comes across as secure in himself. Embraces Saban and Alabama traditions but has his own ideas. Early appearances are that he'll look at every aspect of the program, compare his way to "what Alabama's always done before," and choose the best aspects of both.
Respectful of Saban's success and Alabama tradition. Wants to learn from both, but not intimidated by or beholden to either.
After Bryant died (about a month to 6 weeks after Perkins was hired), Perkins wanted to erase everything related to Bryant. While a lot of the hangers-on -- boosters and Athletic Department employees -- needed to be nudged out, Perkins was unnecessarily abrasive in doing so. I've always thought that if Bryant had lived another year, he could have helped round off some of Perkins' sharp elbows.
DeBoer is light years more polished in implementing his changes.