The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly… LSWho style:

[Bama Lee]

The Good- the defense played lights out. Everyone deserves kudos, but special shout to Pierre! Special shout to Doud for another phenomenal games.

The Bad- offensive play calling was bad. The OL struggled again. Some of those play designs running are head scratchers. Why are kickers Psycho.

The Ugly- whole LSU team looked really to lose after the way we played

 

[Windsortide]

The Good=The Defensive effort
The Bad= Leaving points on the board with missed throws
The Ugly= LSWho’s Offense

 

[RdunawayTX]

The good: Defense. They won that game.
The bad: Ty was off tonight. I'm going to extend grace and say everyone has an off night.
The ugly: Puke orange. And the O line (also puke).

On an unrelated note, I really want my time back watching that game. Ugh.

 

[Bama_N_Va]

The Ugly - that fourth down play call with 2 mins left, why not kick the FG??

The Bad - Second half play calling

The Good - The D wins game ball!!!

 

[RdunawayTX]

The Ugly - that fourth down play call with 2 mins left, why not kick the FG??

The Bad - Second half play calling

The Good - The D wins game ball!!!

Have you watched our kicker?

 

[rolltide_21]

Good- Front seven
Bad- Interior OL
Ugly- Talty’s missed FG

 

[Ledsteplin]

The Good: An SEC win against the corn dogs. Ty Simpson and the recievers. The Defense.

The Bad: No answer to the corn dog blitzes. The run game...again!

The Ugly: Blind refs. Empty bottle of diazepam.

 

[jthomas666]

The Ugly - that fourth down play call with 2 mins left, why not kick the FG??

Better odds. Didn't want to risk a blocked FG.

 

[Bama_N_Va]

Have you watched our kicker?

They missed one, we missed one, even Steven in my book. Had we lost the game by 2 pts, that missed FG is key...If our play calling in the second half was halfway decent, FGs not needed...

 

[TideEngineer08]

I didn't watch; listened to Chris Steward and Tyler Watts. But I'd say

Good: Defense. I had serious doubts that Womack was ever going to be the answer. But he's got those guys playing lights and and some of them are turning into serious monsters. It's a different method, but the results are Saban-like.

Bad: Grubb doesn't seem to be able to design a game plan around the strengths and weaknesses of his offense. It doesn't seem like we self-scouted at all during the bye week.

Ugly: Running game. Is it the OL or the RBs? Or is it coaching? You won't convince me Miller is 100%. Every team has its weak spots, but this one is probably going to be enough to keep this team from winning a championship.

 

[LeBron47]

The Great - The Alabama Defense & the Win
The Good - First Half Ty
The Bad - Second Half Ty
The Ugly - Greg & Whoever is His Side Kick

 

[denver]

Good: defense played lights out, discipline...few penalties
Bad: OC calls, Ty reads when pressured and the OL overall, our kicker
Ugly: Miller running, drops and some weird too cute calls that were not needed

 

[Cruloc]

Good......D

Bad.....offense

Ugly.....offensive execution was ridiculous, coming off a bye no less. Jam getting stuffed running into an OL repeatedly.

 

[merino]

Good: a win, despite the glaring deficiencies, Ryan W great leaping catch
Bad: J Miller's hesitancy, too much dancing, and cannot always blame OL
Ugly : reluctance to try another running back

 

[thunderz7]

For those knocking our kicker; Have you noticed that our holder almost always has the laces turned wrong?

 

[81usaf92]

G: we won and defense
B: our offense
U: Ryan Grubb play calling

 

[Saban4Ever]

Good: we won, our defense won the game for us; our punting; refs were decent for the most part
Bad: Ty seems to fumble once a game now; our offense was not in sync; the deep ball
Ugly: Our running game and play calling on offense; what the score will be next week vs OU if we don't get our run game and offense going.

 

[Isaiah 63:1]

Bad: Grubb doesn't seem to be able to design a game plan around the strengths and weaknesses of his offense. It doesn't seem like we self-scouted at all during the bye week.

Agree. It’s almost as if - and I don’t mean this literally - Grubb spends all his time designing jaw-dropping eye candy plays, at the expense of a customized game plan (strategy) and play calling rhythm (tactics)…

 

[CoolBreeze]

GBU is always a fun thread. Just hope the coaches are reading it because so much truth in it. Shout out to our punter man, talk about an unsung hero of the night. He gets a helmet sticker for sure!

 

[Bruce014]

The Good - We have an elite defense
The Bad - The run game
The Ugly - Too many attempts at gimmick plays, IMHO...

Regarding those gimmicks, though, they are fun to watch. I used to be a "run often, pass rarely" kind of guy, but I've softened as I've gotten old.
A good passing game is a thing of beauty, you just have to be smart about it.